All Stars Sports Bar & Grill Reviews Summary

Category: Bar & grill New York

Address: 327 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019, USA

Phone: +12129561606

Rating: 4.3
based on 204 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "Our server Mariah, took such great care of us - very tentative and friendly."
  • "Can’t say enough about the friendly and attentive service!"
  • "Waiter was very attentive."
  • "Customer service was great! Roge made sure we had everything we needed."
  • "The staff at this place was fantastic!!!! They went out of their way to make sure that you were getting the proper service."
  • "The service of the waiters was phenomenol, They were so attentative."
  • "Service was excellent and the drinks were strong."

Cons:

  • "Food didn’t come out at the same time, some staff were rude."
  • "Please avoid this place at all costs."
  • "Waitress -0 stars: we decided to get a table and be close to watch a game. We sat and waitress came in with the worst attitude asking us what we want."
  • "Expect very slow service... Food took forever to get."
  • "Strike 3 of bad service. 1st time there food took a little over 1.5hrs to come."
  • "The waitress never came back after bringing the food."
  • "The waitress Keila, rude from beginning to end."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food was very good and not badly price for the area."
  • "We tried the Buffalo hot and garlic parm flavors which were great!"
  • "The food was DELICIOUS! Best veggie burger (house made with a family recipe) I’ve ever had in my life."
  • "The traditional Buffalo wings are great."
  • "Solid food."
  • "Food was flavorful (must try the wings) and service on point."
  • "The wings were delicious!"

Cons:

  • "Chicken wings however was incredibly disappointing."
  • "The wings are small, the wingettes were not cut properly (at the joint) and cut at the bone creating bone fragments that made eating them difficult."
  • "Wings were ok but not as good as the original."
  • "Ordered 2 boneless wings dinners; got bone-in."
  • "Food was bland. All star Burgers were dry and had no taste."
  • "The burger was almost unbearable, we asked for medium and medium well, well done is all we got."
  • "Food was not good, I order the pasta with chicken which both were extremely dry and had no taste."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "It's a great place to go after work have a few drinks with friends and just relax."
  • "Sports on at every turn."
  • "Good to watch games."
  • "Big space with multiple rooms, TVs throughout."
  • "It’s a great sports atmosphere."
  • "The interior is spacious, clean, and decorated with sports merch."
  • "A fun spot for both locals and tourists, with a ton of TVs showing whatever is playing."

Cons:

  • "The place has no ambiance (super brightly lite, basic decor and a picture of Hillary Clinton)."
  • "Atmosphere isn’t crazy."
  • "I give it a 3.5 just because I don't like the decor, it's very plain and lighting is odd."
  • "Yes it's loud you have to shout to be heard."
  • "I have absolutely no idea why on earth a 'sports bar' would put club music during sports match, where you can’t hear the actual match, each other, or even the waitress. Obnoxious and aggressively loud. Nope."
  • "Acoustics make it loud (or a group next to us was just exceptionally obnoxious)."
  • "First you have to love really loud head banger music, because it is crazy loud."

Management

Pros:

  • "Prices are reasonable and you can tell Raj, the manager, puts a great deal of care and work into the upkeep and function of the place."
  • "The manager was really friendly and even bought us a round."
  • "The manager and the main servers are great."
  • "Most importantly, the staff treats you like family and are the warmest people I know."
  • "The owner/manager was very accommodating. Made us feel welcome."
  • "They managed the reservations, had excellent seating arrangements, the service was amazing and the food was awesome."
  • "Service, decor, price and food quality were much better than expected."

Cons:

  • "The staff is friendly but this place is poorly managed."
  • "When I rang they had no excuse and offered little to no sympathy."
  • "This is the kind place that is churning people in and out to make an extra buck instead of sticking to their bookings and creating a solid experience for their customers."
  • "No matter what future events there are, we will never ever recommend this place or book it again for any large events."
  • "When I escalated the issue to the manager they were rude and snarky."
  • "Run by the bartenders and each of them has no sense of customer service."
  • "Two weeks and 5 calls later including speaking with the manager Raj, still no refund."

Pricing

Pros:

  • "The bartender is very friendly and doesn't skimp on the pours. 8 dollar cocktails all day."
  • "There was a large selection of food and drink to choose from, all of which were reasonably priced."
  • "Great food great prices!"
  • "Drinks are reasonably priced and include a wide variety of beers, both draft and cans/bottles, and a full bar."
  • "Prices are very reasonable."
  • "Beer buckets reasonably priced."
  • "Food and service always on point for a very fair price!"

Cons:

  • "IF YOU DO NOT REVIEW YOUR BILL THEY WILL OVER CHARGE YOU AN EXTRA $4 TO EACH ITEM !!! BEWARE !!!"
  • "When the bill came, much to our surprise the drinks total was $25!!! Nowhere on the menu did it say that sodas were not bottomless."
  • "They charge a cover of any ppv events or even big games while other bars local and non local don’t."
  • "A little pricey but I would go back."
  • "I was surprised at the tab. 177 for three people. So I'll just keep that in mind next time. Not a cheap bar."
  • "They nickel and dime with no soda refills (really guys, it costs less than $0.25 per glass and you’re charging $3. You can at least do 2 refills)"
  • "Everything was overpriced($6 for a club soda)."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.