Island Burger Reviews Summary

Category: Fast food restaurant Brooklyn, New York

Address: 504 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA

Phone: +17184952474

Rating: 3.9
based on 159 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food is finger-licking, wanting-more great!"
  • "Island burger has the best food in Brooklyn."
  • "The sauces for the barbecue was everything I was craving."
  • "OMG, this little food joint next to the Car Wash on Utica. Their Food Is Divine & It's A Good Value."
  • "salmon burger and sweet potato fries are to DIE for !"
  • "The Food Is Dam Good Delicious As Per Me And My Lady's Taste Bugs Are Concerned."
  • "Great food. Fresh tasting!!"

Cons:

  • "Everything was wrong."
  • "Food was terrible..soggy burgers...unidentifiable turkey burger...salmon burger tasted like chuck light tuna the cheapest one ..very salty ..more like a large tuna paste."
  • "The Salmon appears to be made from canned salmon instead of actual fresh salmon like usual/traditional salmon burgers."
  • "Their burgers no longer taste like they use to it’s more dry with a loud bayleaf taste."
  • "The food which used to be prepared fresh now tastes stale."
  • "The food is not as good as it used to be."
  • "Food there is old and reheated!"

Customer Service

Pros:

  • "The customer service is really good and the employees are helpful."
  • "Service was great πŸ‘."
  • "The cashier lady was very nice."
  • "Customer service, in person is top notch."
  • "The ladies who work here are very welcoming and kind."
  • "The staff outs friendly."
  • "Food was fantastic and the staff were very nice."

Cons:

  • "Poor customer service...rude young ladies answering calls, taking orders."
  • "The owner needs to STOP RESPONDING to reviews and just get the rude employees under control."
  • "The servers at the Utica Avenue location are so rude."
  • "Their customer service is terribly poor. Customer service seems to be only on point when the owner is around."
  • "Customer service is still an issue."
  • "The customer service needs to work on they have been hiring young girls whose attitude is very nasty towards customers."
  • "Horrible absolutely horrible customer service I stayed on hold while trying to place an order for pick up for 30 minutes."

Delivery & Order Accuracy

Pros:

  • "Delivery timeframe was quick but when food arrived it was cold."
  • "I go often and every time the staff is super nice and my food is great."
  • "The food is pretty good here."

Cons:

  • "This place does not read specific instructions for orders and CONSTANTLY mess up the orders to begin with."
  • "I used uber eats to order my food, by the time I got my food it was freezing cold the driver stated they had them waiting."
  • "I was very disappointed with my order today."
  • "Why TF did I get 2 Chicken and Chips, one shrimp with NO CHIPS."
  • "Never again... I call no answer.... I show up and it's too late to take my order."
  • "I also ordered a side of potato salad, which I’m glad I did because I never received the macaroni salad at all."
  • "I ORDERED D ISLAND BURGER WITH FRIES ON SEAMLESS NOT ONLY DID MY ORDER TOOK LONG ABOUT A GOOD 2 HRS TO COME! FOOD WAS SUPER COLD AND WHILE EATING MY BURGER IT'S A FREAKING HAIR IN MY FOOD!"

Hygiene & Safety

Pros:

  • "Everything on the menu is good and made fresh after you order!"
  • "I complimented the chef when I was done and there were smiles in every corner of this tiny takeout gem."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.