"Perry is amazing! She was the only server and greeter on site but took care of everyone."
"The wait staff was exceptional. They really went out of the way to make us feel welcomed and comfortable."
"From the service from Joy who sat us promptly to the freshness of crab and shrimp I was pleasantly surprised!"
"The waiters and waitress were very attentive."
"Our waitress, Joy was truly full of joy she made our experience 100/10."
"Service was great, especially from James."
"The servers are polite, clean and very attentive."
Cons:
"Service was good albeit a bit slow."
"The service was slow, and we had to ask two different servers before getting water."
"Service was slow, took a while to get people’s attention and get dessert / leftovers packed up."
"The service was a little spotty bc it was so busy."
"Your service is horrible. Especially today 08/30/20 @6-7pm shift was rude, disrespectful, not helped, and with a bad attitude!"
"The waitress are also kind rude, and they keep rushing us to pay and leave."
"The server barely came around despite the place mostly being empty."
Food Quality
Pros:
"The food is outstanding - fresh, fantastic flavors, good portions."
"Really delicious seafood and sides! We got the king crab and shrimp with potatoes, corn, garlic bread, and Cole slaw."
"The seafood was fresh and flavorful."
"The food was delicious and seasoned just right."
"The food tasted amazing."
"The food was AMAZING! And the service and environment were wonderful as well."
"The food was great! We shared a fish combo, split it in three and the portion was very sufficient!"
Cons:
"Skip the crawfish, cooked well, but not too flavorful."
"The food of this place has become not so delicious... and is also overpriced."
"Not enough fish in Gumbo, too much sausages in Jambalaya."
"The first thing I noticed when my food arrived was that the shrimp was fully in shell and had not been cut to clean."
"Food was decent, seafood boils had good flavor. Jambalaya was a bit dry."
"The server was so kind, but the poor food."
"It was the worst seafood I've ever had. It was tough and dry."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"Very nice atmosphere, perfect music, and excellent food."
"Having a Great time as we speak Atmosphere is amazing!"
"Nice coastal decor and atmosphere as well."
"Very cute, warm and welcoming vibe!"
"The interior design of the place itself transports you to the boat house of your dream."
"The place is beautifully decorated with an aquatic scenery and wonderful ambiance."
"The nautical ambiance, the decor, the octopus mural, the music & the volume were literally perfect."
Cons:
"Energetic atmosphere; music is a bit loud, which requires raising your voice to have a conversation."
"Where is the great ambiance the reviews are mentioning? It’s a small restaurant with tiny tables on which your order won’t fit, let alone sit comfortably."
"Atmosphere was meh."
"It's really really bright in there! I would've preferred the lights to be turned down 10%, especially for dinner."
"Drink was ok but the food was not flavorful and the music was too loud."
"Was also lied to about a happy hour not existing despite being on a sign outside."
"Was also lied to about a happy hour not existing despite being on a sign outside and one that's very fresh at it too."
Value
Pros:
"Solid price, fast service, great food."
"Pricing is good not too expensive."
"You get a lot for your money and it’s a secret in hell kitchen."
"Good prices overall for drink and food and awesome atmosphere."
"The food is amazing and well priced, so definitely go and enjoy!"
"Our bill came to $70 so very reasonable."
"Great seafood place in Hell’s Kitchen! The price was on the lower side and the food was pretty good."
Cons:
"The food of this place has become not so delicious. The seafood has become very salty and is also overpriced."
"Also, the cost of a 1lb mix was $120 too much. Grossly overpriced for the quality."
"Wouldn't split the checks after making it very clear that we would pay separately as a party of four."
"Then we had an automatic gratuity, which was too high when the service was horrible someone came to our table once through the whole time we was there."
"I got 25% off discount, but actually I would pay nothing for this."
"The portion size was good and the fries were okay but for $25 why would I only want to taste pepper? I would not recommend."
"Not inexpensive, but you are in NY just off Times Square."