"The seafood was incredibly fresh and the margaritas were delicious."
"The seafood was so fresh and delicious!"
"The Dungeness crab was unexpectedly phenomenal."
"Best experience in seafood dining. My Branzino was fresh and tender with a crispy outside."
"The food was fresh, flavorful and perfectly cooked."
"The food was beyond amazing. It was so well seasoned and cooked perfectly."
Cons:
"I ordered the Brooklyn lobster roll and was beyond disappointed! Literally spit out every bite of it i ate into a napkin."
"The Beer Battered Fish was nasty, and mushy. Didn't taste good at all."
"3 out of the last 4 times we got overcooked crab legs."
"The lobster was under cooked a bit."
"Probably the worst food I ever tasted in my entire life. All the chefs should be fired for allowing raw to be served."
"Everything was wack. I regret going here. Tasteless bland food."
"The food was Nasty and overpriced."
Service
Pros:
"Our server was nice and she delivered our correct orders in a timely fashion."
"Very friendly, knowledgeable and pro-active service."
"The wait staff was extremely helpful in providing their opinions and favorites off the menu."
"The hostess and our waiter were definitely very attentive to all of our needs while dining at their restaurant."
"Service was very friendly! Our food came out so fast which was very surprising considering how massive and busy the restaurant was."
"The service was great both of my waiters were polite and everything I asked for I got."
"Service was great, bartender hostess and other staff were all really nice."
Cons:
"Waited 1 hour and 30 minutes to be seated when I was told an hour."
"They don’t work with you. I walked out feeling robbed!"
"The waiter was slow and didn't know a thing about his job any questions were answered 'check the menu'."
"Had to flag down three different servers just to get a drink."
"We were waiting for our server for 20+ minutes before ordering our food."
"The service was slow, unhelpful, and mediocre at best."
"Terrible hostess who ignored us while standing directly in front of her."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"Great day drinking vibe. Fun games and activities."
"The atmosphere was so vibrant!"
"A breezy and relaxing atmosphere."
"It's a great open area and highly recommend it if you are looking for a fun night or as a venue for events."
"The atmosphere is amazing you get to see statue of Liberty through the large sliding doors."
"We love the funky vibe, and the views are amazing."
"It's a cool place to soak up some Red Hook vibes."
Cons:
"The backyard has never reopened."
"The atmosphere was somewhat noisy due to the layout of the floor, but that made it more welcoming for kids anyway."
"The restaurant’s atmosphere was good but the place has strange smell, peel out from the table, everything looks dirty and feels doesn’t neat."
"The whole vibe of the place is divey which is intentional and i understand that, but every surface in there is sticky which was a little gross."
"This place is a zoo. The servers seemed very earnest, but overwhelmed and inefficient."
"Place looks a little run down, just my opinion."
"The upstairs bartenders could be more attentive."
Value
Pros:
"Nevertheless, $26 for 6 chilled crab claws is still $4.33 per claw."
"3 ears of corn for $5 is not a bad price."
"The oysters were a bargain for $1 each."
"Good happy hour - $1 oysters, $5 beer, $8 margaritas (and on a Saturday!)"
"The price is decent for a place that sell real fresh crab non refrigerated."
"The drinks were cheap enough compared to other places in the area."
"It's worth it."
Cons:
"Four of us had a drink, a couple of baskets of calamari (very good), some fries and the 'crab feast' and it was way over $100 per person."
"The prices are in many cases astronomical for what is so-so food and, at least on our visit, subpar service."
"The food however is a bit overpriced. Had to send the crab cakes back because they were so over cooked and mainly filler, not a lot of lump crab meat."
"Prices are exorbitant, so get a good view upstairs because that's what you're paying for."
"Food was over fried, overpriced."
"food is good but overpriced for what it is, as are drinks."
"Not happy at all… came with my family spend $480 and left hungry… food was ok but definitely not worth the money."
Accessibility
Pros:
"It's wheelchair friendly but only the second floor."
"If you come early like before 6: 00 pm you should be able to find parking around the area."
"Outdoor seating is available for warmer days and even some games to keep everyone entertained."
"Brooklyn Crab has three stories of open-air dining, making it a great spot to enjoy lunch or dinner and a view of the Statue of Liberty and waterway."
"Great place for a hot summer day! Can take the ferry to and from Wall Street."
"Parking was on the street and we were there after hours."
"It's an amazing location that totally takes you out of the redhook you know."
Cons:
"There are no elevators so be prepared to get some exercise especially if you have a baby and need to carry their baby car seat and stroller up and down the stairs."
"If you have an electric chair it might be difficult since the tables are either long or small."
"Just be wary there is a lot of steps."
"Got sat at the table at around 6 and they did not have someone come by for over 10 mins with just water then another 10-15 for drinks."
"The place was quiet and relaxing."
"A bit pricey - $21 for a fish and chips."
"The upstairs bartenders could be more attentive."