Big Daddy's Home Plate BBQ Reviews Summary

Category: Barbecue restaurant

Address: 167 Rte 9W, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA

Phone: +18452714024

Rating: 4.5
based on 112 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Both were smoked perfectly and had a nice crust on the outside."
  • "10/10/10/10/10/10 great bbq had the ribs an pulled chicken with mac n cheese and baked beans and corn bread loved it ...loved every bite."
  • "The ribs fall off the bone!"
  • "Super tender, perfectly smoked and amazing taste!"
  • "The BBQ pulled chicken was super flavorful."
  • "Everything was seasoned and the Ribs, pulled pork had the smoke needed to make it flavorful."
  • "The ribs are meaty and juicy, and perfection!"

Cons:

  • "If there was any less than a star...this is the WORST WORST WORST BBQ I even been at...worst $20 I ever spent on food...STAYYYYY AWAYYYYYYY"
  • "Boil your ribs first, you not responsible with the grill. Ribs chewy, dry, waste of my money."
  • "The collard greens (one of my favorite veggies) were SO spicy, not listed on the menu, so that was a bummer."
  • "The fried chicken lacked spices, the pork ends were tough to chew, the corn bread was dry."
  • "Lots of food however it was completely tasteless."
  • "The ribs were tender, huge and juicy but bland to me."
  • "The brisket wasn't tender enough for me."

Service

Pros:

  • "The 1 worker I saw was tremendous, very fast and tentative to the short line."
  • "Everyone was attentive and very polite, even the owner himself!!"
  • "There were two guys working; I believe father and Son. Very very kind, Made good conversation, And outstanding food."
  • "Very friendly staff even dealing with the restrictions of the pandemic."
  • "Owner and staff are super nice and friendly!"
  • "The gentlemen that worked tonight (5/16.. 6:30pm) were so sweet, accommodating and hard working."
  • "The young man serving us at the counter was very attentive and professional."

Cons:

  • "The service was very very slow."
  • "I am so dissatisfied with the service and I do not recommend."
  • "Not very friendly."
  • "Definitely will not be going back there again."
  • "We had to wait 20 minutes for this takeout."
  • "When we called the restaurant to complain there was no offer to even deliver us more food."
  • "Using a microwave to warm up food this place sucks worst food and nasty kitchen this place needs a major overhaul where is Chris Ramsey for this place and chicken is just grilled No way this place can call themselves barbecue"

Ambiance and Cleanliness

Pros:

  • "The appearance was drab and disheveled, definitely not inviting."
  • "Atmosphere was very welcoming and felt like home."
  • "Walking in the door you notice the friendly family atmosphere."
  • "The vibe was very warm and homey."
  • "Great prices, comfortable and relaxed ambiance, very clean."
  • "Love the food, loved the service and the down home country feel!!"
  • "The service was excellent and the food was good."

Cons:

  • "Place was filthy and needed a good cleaning."
  • "The place is not fancy at all."
  • "It looked closed/out of business at first."
  • "They are not open for dining, just take out."
  • "Local place. Atmosphere more suited to pick up than eat in."
  • "The one big caveat I'd give to anyone who's not familiar with the location - the parking situation is ROUGH."
  • "BEWARE - A cat's nail was found in my food."

Value

Pros:

  • "Very nice people, I would give it another try only because they did give great portions."
  • "By far the best chicken I’ve had in rockland."
  • "Great prices."
  • "Fair warning come hungry because you are going to leave this place a couple pounds heavier then when you came in but trust me it is worth every pound."
  • "Value of food is worth it, excellent customer service."
  • "The portions are decent and the price is decent."
  • "The food 🍲 was very delicious and prices were quite reasonable."

Cons:

  • "The Mac and cheese needs to come in larger sizes πŸ˜€."
  • "It's a little pricey, especially for the area."
  • "I hear they are expensive and personally they don't stand out taste wise."
  • "Unfortunately both the dining room and the local State Park were closed so we had to return home to eat more than an hour later."
  • "First timer Very nice people but wings are not good or fresh, they have a frost bitten taste/texture to them."
  • "If you’re looking for β€œsmoked” BBQ THEN DON'T go here. I am a Bbq fan and the only smoke the brisket n ribs received was from the grease splattering on the side of the oven."
  • "Not eating from here again.....ordered the bbq chicken...... disgusting."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.