Cathryn's Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The squid ink pasta with rock shrimp was absolutely delicious!"
• "Delicious food and great service!"
• "Food was great! Loved the pasta, tried some of the salmon scrambled eggs too which were also delicious 😋"
• "Food was very delicious."
• "Everything we ordered was wonderful."
• "The fettuccine con fiori di zucchini was so flavorful and well-balanced."
• "The succulent meat practically melted in my mouth, and the accompanying flavors were a symphony of delight."

Cons:

• "Food was flavorless and got me sick."
• "Ravioli was not fresh."
• "Pasta lacked flavor too."
• "Unfortunately my meal wasn't that great to be honest It was kind of bland."
• "The lobster ravioli was barely defrosted and freezer burned and may have been more palatable as breadsticks."
• "The food was not good. We returned the cacio e Pepe dish."
• "The spaghetti was stale and tasteless."

Service

Pros:

• "Equally commendable was the warm and attentive service provided by the staff."
• "The staff was beyond accommodating and so friendly."
• "We have always been served consistently excellent food by Peter who is personable, attentive and accommodating."
• "A special shout out to the wait staff, esp- Sean who's extremely friendly and courteous."
• "Service was excellent. Staff were all helpful and courteous."
• "The staff was friendly and engaging and had my girlfriends and I enjoy our day out."
• "Theresa, our server was kind and accepting."

Cons:

• "I think the staff needs more training."
• "Food was okey but waitress was very rude."
• "When I asked him if he could recommend a cocktail suitable for women, he refused, telling us to choose for ourselves."
• "It is unfortunate the service received from our waiter. Poor attitude with arrogance."
• "Service was terrible. Just terrible experience."
• "We were badly served by a tall, middle-aged man."
• "The food comes very slow, overcooked and i wouldn't say the taste was worth the wait."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "Atmosphere is nice, restaurant is clean."
• "The atmosphere is beautiful at night."
• "Beyond the delectable cuisine and welcoming service, the ambiance of Cathryn's added another layer to the dining experience."
• "They’ve clearly put care into the decor/atmosphere of the place - dim but warm lighting with pretty things to look at."
• "The restaurant has a trendy Tuscan vibe, perfect for a romantic dinner."
• "Ambiance 💯👌👌👌"
• "A delicious Italian restaurant situated right in the middle of Cold Spring."

Cons:

• "Some may consider this place pricey for the portion sizes but I know quality when I taste it."
• "Portions were SMALL, prices were HIGH (for what you got)."
• "The food is super expensive."
• "Cold Spring in general has lost its family friendly feel."
• "The wines by the glass are quite limited."
• "Bathroom trash can was full with paper overflowing, we ate early so it must have been from the night before."
• "Slightly pricey, but reasonable."

Price and Portion Size

Pros:

• "Some may consider this place pricey for the portion sizes but I know quality when I taste it."
• "Everything was pricey (about $50/person), but you're paying for great food."
• "Food was delicious, fresh and reasonably priced."
• "Portion size were a bit small for the pastas, but still pretty filling."
• "Pasta is homemade so that’s a plus."
• "They even have vegan options (especially the risotto - I added mushrooms and it was delicious.)"
• "The four cheese and pear sacchetti is to die for."

Cons:

• "Portions were SMALL, prices were HIGH (for what you got)."
• "The food is super expensive."
• "However, the portions are tiny small."
• "A bit pricey, though."
• "A bit overpriced for the amount of food tho."
• "All those slightly expensive."
• "This is not a family friendly establishment."