Colarusso's Coal Fired Pizza Reviews Summary

Category: Pizza restaurant

Address: 280 Main St, Dickson City, PA 18519, USA

Phone: +15704892627

Rating: 4.4
based on 121 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Delicious coal-fired pizza in an unsuspecting strip mall."
  • "The appetizers were so good (Warning: Very addictive wings)."
  • "The Sophia Loren pizza was outstanding! I could eat that pizza every day!"
  • "Fantastic pizza one of the best in the area."
  • "Their traditional pizza comes out perfect every time."
  • "The salads are HUGE.... All the appetizers are Delicious! The PIZZA IS AMAZING."
  • "The calamari WAS DELICIOUS! AND there was a lot of it for one person it could have easily been for 2 people."

Cons:

  • "Somewhat disappointed in the Sicilian pie. Not a fan of the crust."
  • "So, we paid $60 for some dough with a tiny bit of toppings!"
  • "I've never seen pizzas with such scant toppings!!"
  • "The pizza was so burnt on the bottom that’s all we could taste."
  • "Usually don't post bad reviews, however, ordered a baked Italian sub and it was really bad. Meat was still cold."
  • "Ordered Margarita pizza and was very disappointed because the dough was tasteless and reminded me of cardboard."
  • "This was some burnt crust hipster pie with one sprig of basil on my margherita pie."

Service

Pros:

  • "The service is always friendly and prompt."
  • "We’ve always received our dishes promptly and without delay."
  • "Service was excellent."
  • "The staff were fantastic and didn't have to wait."
  • "With every occasion they took excellent care of us."
  • "Greeted and seated immediately for lunch."
  • "Joe was my bartender, and he was very attentive!"

Cons:

  • "I have now called four times with no resolution and now I feel like I was stolen from."
  • "Absolutely HORRIBLE experience! Food was terrible and not to mention the manager had a HORRIBLE attitude."
  • "Food was great but service was horrible."
  • "Wait staff wasn't really friendly and it was hard to get their attention when we needed something."
  • "The waitress/hostess wiping down the tables was quick to snap at us that they don’t open until 4."
  • "Terrible customer service!"
  • "The wait staff was rude/ not friendly and seemed condescending."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "Nice atmosphere for a younger crowd....has that New York college feel to it."
  • "The ambiance and decor made the dining experience a stellar evening!"
  • "The outdoor patio is great when the weather permits."
  • "They have a very nicely appointed private room for parties, gatherings and special occasions."
  • "Big screen tv's line the walls so that your bound to catch your favorite sports team in action."
  • "Amazing classy setting."
  • "Very nice casual friendly atmosphere to boot."

Cons:

  • "The only thing I don't like is the acoustics in the area by the bar."
  • "The chairs outside are narrow and uncomfortable."
  • "It was close to closing time and they cleared the table before we were done."
  • "We went on a Saturday and it was loud."
  • "Pizza is great. However customer service sucks. The cooks and servers are very childish and secretly discriminate if you are not from their background."
  • "Hours are always wrong says open then go there says they're closed."
  • "Good food...but your staff in the conference room needs to learn etiquette when it comes to dealing with a business meeting..."

Value

Pros:

  • "Very reasonably priced for portion and quality."
  • "The bill was even affordable!"
  • "Great menu at reasonable prices."
  • "Lots of good indoor and outdoor seating, especially for a pizza place."
  • "The prices are very fair for these economic times in the food industry."
  • "One of the best pizza place in Scranton."
  • "A great late night dining experience and highly recommended."

Cons:

  • "Items are a tad expensive **."
  • "Especially after spending $70. We would have enjoyed a $10 burger n fries at the local diner more I think."
  • "Add 4 drinks, total came to $77."
  • "Lots of unprofessionalism, which we were definitely more upset about than the pizza."
  • "Would come here every weekend if I could afford it."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.