Quality Italian Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The food was wonderful and the dishes plentiful, especially the desserts!"
• "They are obviously known for the Chicken Parm Pizza and it is definitely a must have!"
• "The desserts were two cakes for our guests bday and the chocolate cake was the best small but rich cake and was honestly the perfect size."
• "The lobster pasta was my favorite!"
• "The Classic chicken parm pizza was good."
• "The calamari was perfectly fried and done well."
• "Everything we tried was amazing. From the appetizers to the desserts."

Cons:

• "Food was underwhelming had the chicken parm pizza, lobster pasta, and the baked clams - everything was below average."
• "But it didn’t have any spice and the pasta tasted inauthentic or not quality Italian."
• "Unfortunately, the calamari appetizer did not exhibit any noteworthy qualities."
• "The main dishes were lacking in flavor."
• "The meat, though well-cooked, suffered from slight over-searing."
• "The accompanying sides, particularly the tough and grass-like broccoli, failed to complement the dish."
• "The lobster pasta was good, but the tail was overcooked and stuck to the shell."

Service

Pros:

• "Service was good but was a bit scattered."
• "Our waiter was initially cold but he warmed up and experience ended up being fine."
• "Our waiter he was amazing. Super patient with us very nice and was the best."
• "The staff is definitely accommodating and will make adjustments to make you happy."
• "We thoroughly enjoyed the wonderful food while being looked after by the most attentive staff."
• "Service is exceptional, with a top-notch staff to guide you through this great experience."
• "The service was wonderful, everyone took great care of us."

Cons:

• "Service was slow and inattentive."
• "Our server took a long time to come to our table."
• "Service was pretty slow, to the point it was annoying."
• "Our waitress did not pop up during the meal to ask how anything was."
• "For some reason, our waiter wasn’t very attentive (didn’t refill our waters)."
• "They did miss a thing in our order and served it in the end when we were done eating."
• "The place is great, but the service let it down, in particular the waiter."

Ambiance

Pros:

• "Great time with a bestie from out of town. I thought the atmosphere and food were great."
• "The restaurant has a fun atmosphere, where everyone seemed comfortable regardless of what they were wearing."
• "The restaurant itself is decorated with style which is the cherry on top."
• "Probably one of the most amazing dinners I’ve had in NYC. Atmosphere and food was a 10/10."
• "Ambiance in this restaurant is amazing and staff was very kind and they set the standard for authentic Italian food."
• "The ambience is really classy, low lighting, tables prepared beautifully."
• "The ambiance is chic, just the right amount of noise of full tables having an enjoyable evening."

Cons:

• "It just doesn't seem like they care about your experience."
• "Also it feels it has become even more loud, i barely could hear my friend from the opposite side of the long rectatable."
• "The atmosphere is very loud."
• "The ambiance was rather noisy."
• "And the overall conversation sound level was pretty high."
• "On the other hand it was so noisy we could barely hear each other."
• "This is not a peaceful nook to whisper sweet nothings into your date’s ear: you’re going to be yelling over the other patrons."

Value

Pros:

• "Excellent dinner after a show at radio city and the price point was pretty good."
• "Overall, fantastic drinks, amazing pasta, terrific bread, and reasonably priced."
• "The serving size and price both seemed very fair considering where we were dining."
• "Yes, it’s a little pricey, however, I was really impressed by their portion sizes."
• "The prices are on the higher end but you also get quality ingredients and good service."
• "Pricey, but worth every cent."
• "Fair prices, great quality, amazing dessert and stellar customer service."

Cons:

• "$14 liter of water :("
• "I don’t really feel like the parm was worth the price they asked for."
• "Food was sub par and very expensive."
• "Spent $600 here just to be approached by management and then accused of stealing a ceramic Santa cup?"
• "I think this place is a solid 3 out of 5... it's not a good value."
• "It’s definitely not the cheapest place in New York."
• "For a place of this caliber and cost, it definitely falls short of where it should be."