The Hattery Stove & Still Reviews Summary

Decor and Atmosphere

Pros:

• "The decor and layout of this historic place is very unique."
• "Splendid atmosphere, with very quirky and fun decor."
• "The atmosphere was unique and welcoming."
• "Fun decor with lots of great and quirky light fixtures."
• "Wonderful eatery in a restored hotel, unique setting with great imaginative decor."
• "Charming and fun decor with a really cool vibe."
• "Amazing decor and atmosphere that puts you back in time to a speakeasy feel."

Cons:

• "We were seated downstairs at a table by the server kiosk and it was pretty chilly."
• "She said that it was darker downstairs."
• "The main eating area is a bit crowded, so you may end up having a public conversation without trying."
• "The atmosphere was more of a goth night club that was just opening up for the night."
• "Also, they sat us downstairs, which is super dark and gloomy. It looks like a dungeon."
• "We were seated in the windowless basement where there are no other patrons."
• "We were seated at the table nearest the door which made for a drafty dining experience."

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The food here was amazing."
• "The food was large portions and delicious from salad, to meals to dessert I say order it all!!!"
• "I ordered the Ahi tuna melt and it was delicious!"
• "The food was excellent."
• "Good food at a reasonable price."
• "The shrimp tacos were delicious!"
• "The French onion soup is a meal in itself!"

Cons:

• "It's the way of the world these days but $25 for a glorified Swanson's chicken pot pie?!?"
• "Very disappointed that the food was overpriced and underdone and honestly, it wasn’t as good as described on the menu."
• "Molé sauce had a strange taste on the backend."
• "Little dry, but it was good."
• "The 'pie' was served in a shallow soup bowl with some sort of tortilla crust on top... wasn't much flavor to the crust or the pie, and way too much cream."
• "The mushroom tagliatelle was on the saltier side, heavy on the sage as well that overpowered the dish."
• "The chicken on the Chicken or the egg sandwich was overcooked as was the bacon."

Service

Pros:

• "The bartender, Kennedy, is great. He's social but not overly chatty, he makes great drinks and offers interesting perspectives."
• "Our server was stella, she did a really good job! Just enough of asking if were okay and even gave us recommendations."
• "Service was excellent."
• "Staff was super friendly."
• "Staff are attentive yet not overbearing."
• "Service was even better."
• "The wait staff are always super friendly and attentive."

Cons:

• "The server was courteous and apologetic, but it didn't help the experience any."
• "Service was slow but they kept the water glasses full."
• "Server took order and only came back with check."
• "After not being treated with the slightest bit of dignity, we were placed at the table closest to the door."
• "The waiter never checked on us."
• "Our server didn't really seem to care if we had what we needed or not."
• "Service was lacking. They rather chit chat with themselves than wait on you."