"The tomahawk ribeye. Always medium rare. It was really tender and juicy."
"The food was excellent, cooked to perfection and properly seasoned."
"Great flavors and very tender."
"The tuna tartare was phenomenal, the filet mignon was deliciously cooked and the lamb chops are amazing."
"This is simply the best steak I’ve ever had."
"The rib-eye steaks are very, very good indeed."
"The steak was spectacular and perfectly medium rare."
Cons:
"However, it had no flavor! All I could taste was the carbon from the burnt pieces."
"The steak was overcooked without any flavor, beef tartare and tuna tartare are both bland and greasy (not marinated well), dessert is too sweet and even can't compare to the sweets you get at your local grocery."
"Overall the meat is not bad but I think the searing was too charred to the point where it affects the overall taste of the meat."
"The apps and other sides were a bit subpar for elite steakhouses (especially the Canadian bacon and tartare)."
"Steak was delicious. Needed a little bit more flavor and lobster in the mac and cheese with lobster."
"The steaks are not cooked very well, very unevenly cooked as if they were trying to send out these dishes as fast as possible with no flavour."
"The ribeye was burnt and bitter at some areas, and some of the fat chewy like it wasn't properly rendered."
Service
Pros:
"The service was very good. Our main server even stated they could cook something off menu if we wanted."
"Our server, Yasar Is absolutely brilliant! He's friendly and attentive."
"Service is always great and attentive."
"Service was excellent."
"The service was fantastic - a credit to the personable and professional staff."
"Service is exceptional. I went with friends and my son who is special needs. They were not only on top of what he needed and engaged him well, they gave him a tour of the kitchen."
"Service at table was very efficient and friendly and helpful. Very professional."
Cons:
"After an hour of trying to get a manager he finally came over and when we explained our problem with the service all he said was he will talk to them about it."
"Attempts by staff to compensate their blunders were pitiful."
"One guy who was replacing our plates were putting it very rudely onto the table."
"The waitress was terrible. She slammed things done on the table, mixed up all the orders."
"After 25 minutes of making on and off eye contact with our server he never walked over to asked how the food was or if we needed anything else."
"Waiter messed up the order and forgot my steak and other sides."
"Very disappointed to have my server walk up and take the bread that me and my wife were eating away when we had it on our plates without saying a word."
Ambiance
Pros:
"The decor is perfect, and the ambience, fantastic."
"They treat you like family here."
"Walk into a movie set from the 60s, 70s here and have that NY dinner you've seen!"
"The mood was energetic last night with several birthdays."
"Ambiance = 5/5 Excellent. Beautiful modern clean looking restaurant that boasts a full bar and two main dining rooms."
"The classic, soft, and attractive decorations, combined with the moody and relaxing lighting, made for a truly enchanting experience."
"Atmosphere and service were excellent."
Cons:
"Atmosphere- Very loud more like a high-end sports bar then a high-end restaurant."
"Why a TV in the middle of the dining room (not behind the bar) in such a fantastic restaurant?"
"Traditional NY steakhouse that is boisterous .... If you're looking for quiet then take that into consideration."
"A traditional NY, bustling, loud space with a mostly male crowd."
"While the restaurant was nicely decorated for the holidays, it really felt out of place to have a TV playing a football game in the back room."
"Very crowded and noisy at the restaurant too. You can barely hear each other."
"Kind of a uptight atmosphere."
Value
Pros:
"Fabulous steaks at a good price point."
"Yes the prices are higher than most people are used to paying, I assume, but it is an experience/restaurant that far exceeds just the price alone."
"The prices is moderate for the food you getting."
"Price was well within reason for the service received."
"Value = 5/5 Excellent. Belongs in the top 10 Steakhouses in Manhattan."
"I think it is an excellent restaurant and good value for the quality."
"Given this great experience, where also the waiter contributed very much, the price tag at the end was more than fair. Really good price value ratio you can find here!"
Cons:
"We will never come back. I wouldn't recommend it either."
"Won't come again."
"The real very serious problem was at the time of the bill. The waiters played on the misunderstanding, making us pay the bill first and then the tip separately."
"Pricing- Expensive up there with all the high-end steakhouses in NYC."
"This place is not cheap, but you are getting what you pay for."
"It was pricey."
"Cocktails overpriced (no prices listed on the menu, ~$20) and bread cold and dry."