Moustache Pitza Reviews Summary

Category: Middle Eastern restaurant New York

Address: 29 7th Ave S, New York, NY 10014, USA

Phone: +12122292220

Rating: 4.6
based on 179 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food is delicious, authentic, and clean."
  • "The specialties - falafel plate, Moussaka, and lentil soup with rice - satiated our taste beds well."
  • "The freshly baked pita with Muhammara was our favorite."
  • "The food is always fresh, perfectly made, delicious and flavorful."
  • "The lamb was tender and well-seasoned, the tomato was charred and sweet, and the rice was fluffy and aromatic."
  • "The food was beyond delicious! Everything tasted super fresh and was very well seasoned."
  • "The spices were perfectly balanced. Authentic take on middle eastern cuisine."

Cons:

  • "Great food but I feel off late, when the owners are not there the staff are rather rude and feel like they just hate it when customers are there."
  • "Some were good but could use more spice (Nivik, Avocado) and others not so much (roasted cauliflower was a disappointment and served cold)."
  • "Everything tasted old."
  • "The chicken kebab was just foul. Watered down, soggy, burnt mess."
  • "Falafel plate was good, not great. Lamb in the kebab was bland. Don’t bother ordering."
  • "The food was horrible, the checked was raw. My friend had food poisoning because of the raw chicken."
  • "Lastly, bread came uncooked - like in yet dough state like when you pinch it, its just like a dough."

Service

Pros:

  • "The people who work there were kind and the place is nice."
  • "Service was great, we waited about 15 minutes for a table on a Saturday afternoon which wasn’t too bad."
  • "Mark was so gracious and made us feel like family upon seating us."
  • "Amazing food and even better service and people."
  • "The service is phenomenal and the staff are beyond friendly."
  • "The service is EXCELLENT, the staff genuinely goes above and beyond and the food is outstanding!"
  • "The staff are well trained and wore a warm smile throughout the entire evening."

Cons:

  • "No apology or reconciliation was offered."
  • "Service can be a bit...quirky - you definitely have to flag down the servers when you want something to happen."
  • "They seated us a couple of minutes later and proceeded to not serve us water and no complimentary bread when everybody around us was receiving both the water and bread."
  • "The waitress actually rolled her eyes at myself and my brothers because we didn’t know they were cashless."
  • "The staff and the Manager were so rude, not friendly at all."
  • "She has got to be the worst waitress ever in the history of service industry."
  • "Our waitress was cold and never throughout the hour experience did she come to the table on her own will."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "Inside seating was very cozy, and they have outdoor seating (not winter friendly)."
  • "I really enjoyed the vibe as well overall treatment."
  • "An incredible local gem, with really good 'pitza'--heavily recommend the Lahambajin Lamb pizza."
  • "Sweet little spot with great ambiance."
  • "It wasn't loud or crowded, which we really appreciated."
  • "The restaurant is so beautiful and cozy. Their outdoor dining is really nice too, with really warm heat lamps."
  • "Cozy and authentic atmosphere with dim lighting and beautiful tree lined streets of west village architecture."

Cons:

  • "The place is cramped but they have great food and very very affordable."
  • "It's a little small inside though."
  • "There were HUGE COCKROACHES running around the dining room floor while patrons ate their dinner."
  • "For being cash only, cold and out of bakhlava, I give this place 3 points."
  • "Expensive for what you get."
  • "I found this restaurant to be dirty that the table was so dirty and had to wipe myself."
  • "We had a reservation for Saturday night but still had to wait for a while."

Payment and Pricing

Pros:

  • "So glad they now take credit card."
  • "Really rea$onable Perrier."
  • "What we liked was a menu which is really well priced."
  • "Very good price for the quality of meals we had - would recommended 100%!"
  • "All at an incredibly reasonable price."
  • "This is the best Mediterranean food I have ever had. Delicious, flavorful, masterfully done."
  • "The food is fresh, healthy and known to locals as the best Mediterranean food in the neighborhood."

Cons:

  • "This is cash only."
  • "There is no sign stating that they are cash only (not on the doors or anywhere I looked) so they should stop giving people the horrible attitude and mention it when they seat people."
  • "It's a cash only restaurant and we didn't know about that since we are visiting NYC!"
  • "I see the owner mentioned he has an ATM yet many people including myself have been directed to go and find an ATM."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.