Category: Seafood restaurant Montclair, New Jersey
Address: 10 Park St, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
Phone: +19733375227
Rating: 4.9
based on 275 reviews.
Food Quality
Pros:
"The portions are generous, and the prices are reasonable considering the quality of the food."
"Very fresh and the hot captain Louie sauce was perfectly seasoned with the right amount of heat."
"Food was definitely amazing! Gotta try the garlic noodles and dip it in the sauce!!"
"The king crab legs were huge! Oysters were fantastic!!"
"The garlic noodles was bursting with flavor and the perfect pairing for a boil or anything on the menu!"
"The food was delicious and fresh, cooked perfectly with a deliciously famous Capt Loui seasoning."
"The seafood is just perfect, with a variety of options to choose from including crab, shrimp, clams, mussels, and more."
Cons:
"All overcooked and what a disappointment! The clams were inedible and I tried every one and each one went in the tiny discard bucket."
"Flavors and seasonings were not strong/bland and it was disappointing."
"The mussels were not fresh at all and some of the crab legs had a peculiar taste to them."
"More than half of the crab legs were still nearly frozen."
"The snow crabs were so-so and the butter was not real drawn butter."
"Didn't like the noodles. I was looking for ramen and they gave me linguini."
"The food was great except crawfish because they were very small and couldn’t even taste them properly."
Service
Pros:
"Staff are nice, especially Kay is an amazing server. She kindly explained all about their food."
"Amazing customer service!"
"The service was top notch."
"Our server was very friendly and checked in with us periodically."
"Our server was so sweet and attentive throughout the stay."
"Our waitress Yasemin was excellent."
"Our server Kay was extremely kind and sweet."
Cons:
"I don’t know if the Host was the only employee today but he completely ignored my friend and I."
"Upon arrival garbage bags piled on sidewalk in front of entrance."
"Calling the restaurant, I encountered a disrespectful employee who dismissed my concerns and even hung up on me when I requested to speak to a manager."
"Came here on a Thursday evening very empty maybe 3 other tables were occupied."
"The staff is incredible and very kind but the dollar oysters on Tuesday gave two of my friends and I food poisoning."
"This was one of the most disappointing experiences I've had in months, made especially negative by the unethical business practices I saw with my own eyes."
"Long story short I got food poisoning stomach hurts so much lost all sleep."
Ambiance
Pros:
"Great ambiance, good music. Very clean and spacious."
"The building is gorgeous."
"The atmosphere inside is great, music is great, and the decorations they had hanging around really brought the place together."
"love the ambiance of this place! super cute and the lights are so adorable."
"Enjoyed the atmosphere and friendly service."
"The ambiance is welcoming and the location very clean, which I love!"
"The atmosphere was absolutely gorgeous. It really gave spooky vibes."
Cons:
"Only down side is their presentation, but it’s a new restaurant they’ll find their flow."
"Parking is a mess in this area but I’m used to it."
"Only thing with Montclair is that parking is not so great."
"If it’s a busy night parking may be a challenge."
"The atmosphere was relaxing."
"It's nice and quaint Music is not too loud. You can still have a conversation with who you are with."
"The service was very nice however and atmosphere was chill and enjoyable."
Value
Pros:
"$19.99 lobby’s on Thursday’s is the BEST way to cruise into the weekend."
"The food was AMAZING!! The pricing was reasonable!"
"The portion sizes are enough for days to come."
"We were blown away by the flavors and service, pricing was great too!"
"The food was...well portioned as well as reasonably priced."
"The pricing was a bargain for the quality and love that was put into the meal."
"The prices are very reasonable the food is fresh and the portions are great."
Cons:
"The drink I had was a little sugary but that could just be me."
"Food is just ok but refrain from using so…sooo much plastic in this place."
"Nothing is biodegradable being used here and create waaaay too much plastic landfills this way!"
"The cost was pricey for such a small portion and especially extra charge for the sauce was surprising."
"The issues I had were: 1: the Cajun fries, not so good. 2. I ordered a lb of snow crab legs, looked like 1/2 lb."