Vincentown Diner Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "This is the only diner I have been to in quite some time that actually seasons and cooks their food well."
• "The spicy chicken sandwich was fantastic. Mashed potatoes and mac and cheese are awesome too."
• "The tiramisu was to die for absolutely incredible."
• "The roast turkey dinner was delicious. The turkey was real roast turkey, the potatoes were smashed redskin real potatoes."
• "Visited many times and no matter what we order, it’s always delicious!"
• "Loved the food. I had the Country fried chicken while my wife had the cinnamon French toast with a side of bacon."
• "The corned beef hash is the best I've had at a diner in NJ."

Cons:

• "Another said the meatballs were dry - noticing a trend here."
• "Grilled chicken came out with a slice of ham on top, and some kind of weird cheese that didn’t taste like cheese."
• "Grand daughter ordered a burger and fries, burger was supposed to be well done, only the fries were burnt, Burger was raw."
• "We ordered mozzerella sticks which were all batter, no mozzerella."
• "Who puts gravy on a nice pastry? Why did you put grey gravy on my chicken pot pie?"
• "Both of our meals were beyond disappointing. His pot pie was saturated with butter and my eggplant was hard and seemed as if it was right from the freezer."
• "Also we ordered their famous fried chicken and were not impressed. I think it must be batter fried because the mid-layer was doughy."

Service

Pros:

• "We have never had a bad meal here and the wait staff is always friendly and professional."
• "Nikole was our waitress and her service was outstanding."
• "Our server is one of the best there (Kat), she really handled our group with great care and excellent service."
• "Our waiter was outstanding and knowledgeable of the menu items; he was on point with taking our orders and delivered accordingly."
• "Servers were kind, hospitable, and attentive, without being overbearing in their service."
• "The service was exceptional. Everyone seemed busy but it looked well organized."
• "Our server Edgar was fantastic, super attentive and fun."

Cons:

• "Service was a bit slow after we finished eating to wait for our check."
• "The waitress who brought our food threw my husband's plate onto the table and almost spilled my plate onto me as she threw my plate down!"
• "Secondary complaint is the attitude of some of the servers. Some are amazing, but others barely have a personality."
• "The waitress was not personable at all."
• "The hostess was inflexible and the manager was completely unmoved and unsympathetic."
• "Waitress was slow to come back."
• "Our server was very unfriendly (He still received a 20% tip.). He had no personality for this job."

Atmosphere & Cleanliness

Pros:

• "They have a nice porch where you can eat outside."
• "The atmosphere is great!"
• "Relaxed and comfortable atmosphere with clean facilities."
• "The place itself is tidy and neat with a very pleasant atmosphere."
• "The inside was very bright and clean. This was an older diner that was refurbished and the new design looks good while keeping with a classic diner vibe."
• "Very clean, lovely atmosphere."
• "Nice relaxed atmosphere."

Cons:

• "Freezing cold inside. Bring a coat or sweatshirt."
• "We were seated in the dinning room so we didn't get that cozy vibe."
• "It smells unclean like old dish water or something (can't put my finger on it)."
• "Place is dirty! From sitting out in lobby looking up at bugs and water marks, to sitting in sucken in booth."
• "Unfortunately the atmosphere is very loud, list of. List people and loud rock music."
• "The entire place smelled like salmon but not in a good way."
• "We were seated near a window with disgustingly dirty blinds and the upholstery on the booth looked dingy as well."

Value

Pros:

• "I thought you got your money's worth, but don't come here expecting a low price menu."
• "There's many vegetarian options and prices were very reasonable."
• "The food portions are great sizes for what you pay."
• "The service was great and prices are reasonable."
• "Well worth the price which was reasonable and it was a healthy serving if you wanted to share with a date."
• "The meal was worth every penny."
• "Good prices for great food."

Cons:

• "It's still too expensive."
• "For a bill that was over $60 it was not worth it."
• "The prices do not fit the quality of food anymore."
• "Very poor quality for $15 omelets."
• "Didn't expect to pay 7.89 for a short stack when a regular order of pancakes is 8.00."
• "Prices are slightly higher than other diners. 1 Breakfast can be $16 on low end, due to charging high for coffee, Sides etc."
• "An over priced disappointment."