Mulino's of Westchester Reviews Summary

Category: Northern Italian restaurant

Address: 99 Court St, White Plains, NY 10601, USA

Phone: +19147611818

Rating: 4.6
based on 137 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "The server, Ramon, was able to rattle off all of the specials without missing a beat."
  • "The service was incredible, it started at the door and continued to our table."
  • "Great service, friendly staff."
  • "Every single member of staff makes you feel more like family than a customer."
  • "Owners, waiters and staff could not have been any friendlier or attentive."
  • "The service alone deserves 5 stars."
  • "The staff is exceptionally attentive anticipating your needs, whether it be fresh black pepper, grated cheese, additional Silverware, pour of the wine, etc."

Cons:

  • "Mulinos is clearly not the same no longer chestnuts or Christmas carollers."
  • "The waiters, and manager were very rude."
  • "The one waiter we had was getting his 20% automatic tip and barely paid attention to us."
  • "The staff including the manager gave us an attitude about changing the linen."
  • "We did not get good table service, we had to flag waitstaff for service."
  • "I was bitterly disappointed by the service of our waiters."
  • "None of our waiters came to apologize for the wait."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food was just delicious, and prepared exactly how we requested."
  • "Highly, highly recommend the stuffed chicken with lobster tail."
  • "The orange ruffee was delicately spiced to not overwhelm the light flavors of the fish."
  • "Everything we ordered was amazing."
  • "Several star dishes including a rich osso bucco, tender burrata."
  • "The food was fabulous."
  • "The steak au poivre was fantastic."

Cons:

  • "There were no top shelf liquors (nothing above Casamigos tequila or MacCallan 12)."
  • "The food was just terrible. We had different dishes and it was edible but no taste."
  • "The sides of spinach and green beans, while delicious, were also lacking in size considering how pricey they were."
  • "All the food was tasteless and the waiter never reminded us that all the vegetables were a la carte."
  • "Main course was a disaster pasta was tasteless and meat was subpar."
  • "But the food was horrible. Ravioli were too hard on the sides and tasted worse than ravioli I could get from my grocery store's freezer."
  • "The food was decent, but average at best considering the expensiveness!"

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "Beautiful place. Great food. Awesome service."
  • "The ambiance is of an amazing old family owned Italian restaurant."
  • "The outdoor garden area is also a beautiful backdrop."
  • "The restaurant is magnificent with both indoor and outdoor seating."
  • "The atmosphere is a 5."
  • "The place is classy and plays the part of an old school Italian restaurant out of the movies."
  • "Beautifully decorated for the holiday season."

Cons:

  • "It makes the establishment seem outdated and beyond its years."
  • "The table was too small and cramped us in anyway."
  • "Although it can get loud when it is full since the tables are close together and the ceilings reflect the sound back down at the tables."
  • "The carpet also needs to be changed as it is bringing a musty smell."
  • "The restaurant was too dark for our tastes. You need a flashlight to read the menu."
  • "People are seated like sardines (Covid aside, it’s uncomfortable)."
  • "Place was packed, service was horrible, didn't take drink order, walked to bar for other drinks."

Value

Pros:

  • "Worth every penny."
  • "The portion size was larger than I expected for a 5 star eatery."
  • "This place is pricey but worth it."
  • "The food is delish & the prices are great!"
  • "Always an outstanding dining experience! The food, staff and ambiance make this a must if you are looking for exquisite Italian cuisine at a reasonable price point."
  • "This place is a gem you would normally find in upscale areas of Manhattan for a reasonable price."
  • "If you’re looking for a high end, extraordinary experience that’s worth the money, look no further."

Cons:

  • "However, it was $90 for 4 colossal-sized shrimp, oysters, and clams!"
  • "It's pretty expensive here, so I would say for a working class guy and wife - more of a special occasion type of place."
  • "The food was decent, but average at best considering the expensiveness!"
  • "The prices are a little high for Italian food."
  • "The wine selection was lacking and overpriced. I saw bottles that I could buy at any liquor store for double if not triple the price."
  • "Also DO NOT ORDER SPARKLING WATER. They charge $8 a bottle for Pellegrino (it's like $2 at your local grocery store) and we got charged for 2 bottles."
  • "Overall, for three people the total bill was well over $300! I would only return for a special occasion."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.