Ellen's Stardust Diner Reviews Summary

Category: Diner New York

Address: 1650 Broadway, New York, NY 10019, USA

Phone: +12129565151

Rating: 4.4
based on 372 reviews.

Atmosphere & Entertainment

Pros:

  • "It's like you're in a Broadway musical, but you can also dine with the music."
  • "The singing servers are incredible, and we were completely dazzled by the whole thing."
  • "The singing and dancing waiters were just phenomenal - each performance was so engaging, it felt like a mini Broadway show with every order."
  • "There are so many talented performers at Ellen's and it creates a feel good environment."
  • "Good value for money considering you are getting a free musical show."
  • "The musical performance from the staff was amazing."
  • "The singing staff was incredibly talented, making it a fun and memorable dining experience."

Cons:

  • "The singing is really loud and I had a hard time holding a conversation with my friend."
  • "Could be considered loud and obnoxious for others."
  • "Singers were entertaining, but some of them definitely did not have fun at what they were doing."
  • "Very loud when performances on."
  • "The music selection was very strange, singing things from the super Mario movie and rap music."
  • "Don't expect to be having conversations over dinner here, though. It’ll be very loud."
  • "It's LOUD.....very loud."

Food Quality & Selection

Pros:

  • "Ellen’s has wonderful, delicious food and an atmosphere to match it."
  • "American breakfast we visited for and my daughter's really enjoyed their pancakes."
  • "Food was delicious and lots of it!"
  • "Millshakes and desserts are very delicious. The plates are full."
  • "Food was WAY better than I expected, and delivered in American portions at totally reasonable prices."
  • "The food was great, I had chocolate chip pancakes and my partner had an omelette which were both devoured very quickly."
  • "The food was delicious πŸ˜‹ and the service was excellent."

Cons:

  • "The food is kinda pricey and in my opinion not the best."
  • "The food is mediocre, yet very pricey. $17 for a milk shake!"
  • "The food itself is very average there’s nothing extraordinary about the food."
  • "But the food is extremely overpriced. $25 for a veggie burger with no toppings."
  • "The food was average and very pricy for what it was."
  • "Food is average and overpriced, but it didn't take away for the overall experience."
  • "The food was mediocre, probably won't be back."

Service & Staff

Pros:

  • "They made everything very assemble to me. I am handicapped and ride a mobility scooter."
  • "Our waiter was perfect, and courteous, he was on point with all the necessities."
  • "Service and staff Amazing and very helpful."
  • "Service was excellent and needless to say, the atmosphere was absolutely rocking!"
  • "Staff very friendly and regularly asked if we needed anything else at our table."
  • "The waiters themselves are incredibly sweet and bubbly, they clearly love their jobs!"
  • "Service was fast and kind."

Cons:

  • "Service could be potentially slow at times but is mostly negligible."
  • "Also, we understand the servers are of course singing half the time and are very busy but when we wanted to pay we struggled for about 20 minutes to get someone’s attention."
  • "Although we had a waiter change half way through which was strange."
  • "However unfortunately our waiter Beau really let us down, treating us with no care."
  • "Service was a bit slow, but it’s understandable given that they are also singing."
  • "The service was bad, but honestly it's bad everywhere in this city."
  • "Waited quite a while for order to be taken but once it was food came fairly quickly."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.