Address: 129 MacDougal St, New York, NY 10012, USA
Phone: +19176393236
Rating: 4.6
based on 291 reviews.
Service
Pros:
"Friendly staff, excellent service and affordable prices."
"Waiter was attentive and 'on the spot' with any needs or requests."
"From the host Vittorio to other staff members like Tamer everyone is super welcoming."
"The staff was really friendly in helping seat a larger group and was patient as we waited for our entire party to show up."
"Our server Alfina, was one of the best servers I’ve ever had."
"The waitstaff are all personable and ready to deliver impeccable service."
"Our waitress was excellent and attentive."
Cons:
"Service provided by Diana was very polite and slow but not as attentive as expected."
"Service was slow and inattentive."
"But the service was slow and bad."
"Service was not great - our waitress kept rushing us."
"Additionally, the service has declined compared to what it used to be. They didn't even refill my water."
"Our waiter got our order wrong and didn’t bring our second drinks until after we were done with our dinner."
"Service was terrible. The server did not bring the second round of beer until asked again."
Food
Pros:
"The lasagna is highly recommended and their pizza is very solid as well."
"Lasagna was solid - loved all the different flavors and styles with my favorite being the Funghi and Pesto."
"The arrabbiata was very flavorful with the right amount of spiciness and pesto was my favorite!"
"We had the pizza and pesto lasagna, super tasty."
"This place is definitely must try for their lasagnas!!"
"Awesome lasagna flight - exceptional one is the one with the shrimp."
"The lasagna flight was super filling and tasty!"
Cons:
"Also their chocolate cake options are usually overly sweet or dense, and this is coming from a real chocoholic."
"The pizza tasted not much better than your average slice you get at your local pizzeria."
"The sauce was fairly bland and the base of both our pizzas, was overcooked and blackened."
"Tastes like noodles, copious amounts of cheese, specks of meat but with no trace of tomatoes, ricotta, or any complex flavors whatsoever."
"Both were completely flavorless. As bland as could be!"
"The lasagna is blah."
"But the food was bland, and none of us wanted to take home leftovers."
Ambiance
Pros:
"They had dividers between the tables and plenty of heaters."
"The vibe is cozy and authentic which matches the level of perfect comfort food you'll be enjoying."
"The garden in the back makes you feel like you are sitting in Italy somewhere enjoying the food."
"All in all this place gave a very cozy Italian restaurant vibe which I love!"
"First the ambience is romantic and cozy. The decor charming and the atmosphere is warm."
"Great place for a late romantic dinner. Candles on every table and lights are down low."
"The ambiance was perfect- you definitely want to be seated out back in the garden."
Cons:
"The vibe was okay, felt it was too loud so it’s definitely not a date place during the evenings."
"The only thing disappointing in was the ability to not sit in the garden."
"Just be leery of the panhandling homeless as they will sneak up behind you to ask for money so stay alert."
"On a weekend their backyard is so loud, it's hard to converse."
"However, the place is way too noisy with all the people talking."
"The garden is very loud and difficult to hear so maybe not ideal for a conversational evening."
"And maybe cause we were seated by the door the atmosphere was noisy as hell and harried."
Price
Pros:
"I was amazed at how affordable and reasonable their prices were, especially with wine service."
"Meals were very reasonably priced."
"The prices are amazing for the value you get, makes you feel like you overpaid for your dinner elsewhere when you stop in for desert."
"Perhaps most impressive is that we got a pizza and two entrees and it was only $70."
"The prices are amazing for the value you get."
"Serve food late which is awesome too! Prices are reasonable ($17-30 entrees, $13 cocktails)."
"Unbelievably reasonable prices and the food is fabulous."
Cons:
"However we payed more than 100 dollars for a rugula salad, a very basic soup and lasagna."
"The lasagna was good but it seem like a very basic and cheap dinner for Valentine’s Day and for paying 100 dollars!"
"This was honestly less than I expected to pay but still wasn’t worth it all together."
"They just basic said the lasagna flight was the best option and I told them I was a waiter I did not have that much money !!!!."
"I will say, 30$ bottle of wine came with a twist off top & that gave me the ick-- last thing i expected was a twist off bottle on a selective wine menu 🤷🏽♀️."
"The tiramisu is delicious too but overpriced."
"The dessert (Raspberry Cheesecake) was underwhelming."