La Lanterna di Vittorio Reviews Summary

Category: Italian restaurant New York

Address: 129 MacDougal St, New York, NY 10012, USA

Phone: +19176393236

Rating: 4.6
based on 291 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "Friendly staff, excellent service and affordable prices."
  • "Waiter was attentive and 'on the spot' with any needs or requests."
  • "From the host Vittorio to other staff members like Tamer everyone is super welcoming."
  • "The staff was really friendly in helping seat a larger group and was patient as we waited for our entire party to show up."
  • "Our server Alfina, was one of the best servers I’ve ever had."
  • "The waitstaff are all personable and ready to deliver impeccable service."
  • "Our waitress was excellent and attentive."

Cons:

  • "Service provided by Diana was very polite and slow but not as attentive as expected."
  • "Service was slow and inattentive."
  • "But the service was slow and bad."
  • "Service was not great - our waitress kept rushing us."
  • "Additionally, the service has declined compared to what it used to be. They didn't even refill my water."
  • "Our waiter got our order wrong and didn’t bring our second drinks until after we were done with our dinner."
  • "Service was terrible. The server did not bring the second round of beer until asked again."

Food

Pros:

  • "The lasagna is highly recommended and their pizza is very solid as well."
  • "Lasagna was solid - loved all the different flavors and styles with my favorite being the Funghi and Pesto."
  • "The arrabbiata was very flavorful with the right amount of spiciness and pesto was my favorite!"
  • "We had the pizza and pesto lasagna, super tasty."
  • "This place is definitely must try for their lasagnas!!"
  • "Awesome lasagna flight - exceptional one is the one with the shrimp."
  • "The lasagna flight was super filling and tasty!"

Cons:

  • "Also their chocolate cake options are usually overly sweet or dense, and this is coming from a real chocoholic."
  • "The pizza tasted not much better than your average slice you get at your local pizzeria."
  • "The sauce was fairly bland and the base of both our pizzas, was overcooked and blackened."
  • "Tastes like noodles, copious amounts of cheese, specks of meat but with no trace of tomatoes, ricotta, or any complex flavors whatsoever."
  • "Both were completely flavorless. As bland as could be!"
  • "The lasagna is blah."
  • "But the food was bland, and none of us wanted to take home leftovers."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "They had dividers between the tables and plenty of heaters."
  • "The vibe is cozy and authentic which matches the level of perfect comfort food you'll be enjoying."
  • "The garden in the back makes you feel like you are sitting in Italy somewhere enjoying the food."
  • "All in all this place gave a very cozy Italian restaurant vibe which I love!"
  • "First the ambience is romantic and cozy. The decor charming and the atmosphere is warm."
  • "Great place for a late romantic dinner. Candles on every table and lights are down low."
  • "The ambiance was perfect- you definitely want to be seated out back in the garden."

Cons:

  • "The vibe was okay, felt it was too loud so it’s definitely not a date place during the evenings."
  • "The only thing disappointing in was the ability to not sit in the garden."
  • "Just be leery of the panhandling homeless as they will sneak up behind you to ask for money so stay alert."
  • "On a weekend their backyard is so loud, it's hard to converse."
  • "However, the place is way too noisy with all the people talking."
  • "The garden is very loud and difficult to hear so maybe not ideal for a conversational evening."
  • "And maybe cause we were seated by the door the atmosphere was noisy as hell and harried."

Price

Pros:

  • "I was amazed at how affordable and reasonable their prices were, especially with wine service."
  • "Meals were very reasonably priced."
  • "The prices are amazing for the value you get, makes you feel like you overpaid for your dinner elsewhere when you stop in for desert."
  • "Perhaps most impressive is that we got a pizza and two entrees and it was only $70."
  • "The prices are amazing for the value you get."
  • "Serve food late which is awesome too! Prices are reasonable ($17-30 entrees, $13 cocktails)."
  • "Unbelievably reasonable prices and the food is fabulous."

Cons:

  • "However we payed more than 100 dollars for a rugula salad, a very basic soup and lasagna."
  • "The lasagna was good but it seem like a very basic and cheap dinner for Valentine’s Day and for paying 100 dollars!"
  • "This was honestly less than I expected to pay but still wasn’t worth it all together."
  • "They just basic said the lasagna flight was the best option and I told them I was a waiter I did not have that much money !!!!."
  • "I will say, 30$ bottle of wine came with a twist off top & that gave me the ick-- last thing i expected was a twist off bottle on a selective wine menu 🤷🏽‍♀️."
  • "The tiramisu is delicious too but overpriced."
  • "The dessert (Raspberry Cheesecake) was underwhelming."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.