Poughkeepsie Steakhouse Reviews Summary

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "The restaurant is inviting, with a cozy and intimate atmosphere that makes you feel right at home."
• "We were greeted by a very friendly man who sat us right next to the fireplace, which was amazing!"
• "This restaurant is very welcoming, loved the background music."
• "It was like an evening getaway."
• "Atmosphere was nice as were seated near the fireplace."
• "What a lovely place! Great music and a fireplace."
• "The ambiance of The Poughkeepsie Steakhouse was exquisite."

Cons:

• "We were disappointed at the ambiance and their mix match decor, it felt like we were at a dinner."
• "The scenery could use some improvement, it wasn't very welcoming, there was no background music and all together just seemed outdated."
• "The place was very uncomfortably cold."

Service

Pros:

• "Friendly good service, food good."
• "We were greeted by a very friendly man who sat us right next to the fireplace, which was amazing!"
• "The service was excellent though."
• "Our server, Kaleigh was warm, friendly and made us feel at home."
• "Service was great and the place was nice."
• "The service at The Poughkeepsie Steakhouse was impeccable."
• "The service provided by Jenna was spectacular."

Cons:

• "The waitress (yanna) did not make any suggestions or recommendation, all together wasn't friendly."
• "I was uncomfortable that her mask kept going below her nose and we had to wait a long time for our food."
• "We waited 1hour and 40 min to the food was served at our table."
• "Service was extremely slow."
• "The waitresses standing by the door mocking people about wearing masks was probably the highlight of the evening."
• "Our server was as rude and incompetent as someone could be."
• "The worst service we have ever received in our entire lives."

Food Quality

Pros:

• "Flavorful food- apps, mains, sides, and desserts were all given equal consideration- delicious all the way around!"
• "Food is excellent."
• "Our family got three different steaks from the menu and two different fish dishes and they were all amazing!"
• "The flavors were well-balanced, and the portion sizes were generous without being overwhelming."
• "The steak was awesome, mouth watering, and cooked just how I ordered it, medium."
• "The carrot chipotle soup is my absolute fav."
• "So far the best Ribeye I’ve had and my wife says the same for her fillet mignon."

Cons:

• "I ordered the full rack of ribs and the entire rack was raw."
• "The BBQ ribs I had were adequate they were nothing to write home about."
• "Chicken Cordon Blue was also below average."
• "It was also over cooked and dry."
• "My steak came out very overdone and my wife's was underdone."
• "A place that says steakhouse you would think the steaks would be awesome. I get my steak which was a big size great. But it had no taste at all."
• "The chicken fingers were overcooked all of the entrees came out 20 mins apart."