Roots Steakhouse Reviews Summary

Category: Steak house

Address: 17 Chestnut St, Ridgewood, NJ 07450, USA

Phone: +12014441922

Rating: 4.3
based on 173 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "Larry takes care of every customer like family. He makes the experience a 10!!!"
  • "Jake, our waiter, was phenomenal! He was attentive, extremely knowledgeable, and really made it a pleasant experience."
  • "Service was excellent. The drinks and the appetizers could not have been better."
  • "Had a holiday party here! Amazing FOOD and GREAT Service!!!!! They literally did everything we asked for and were very accommodating!"
  • "Alex, the bartender, always remembers our drink and dining preferences and makes us feel like family."
  • "Throughout your dining experience, you will receive top notch service."
  • "Had dinner with some friends and I must say service (as always) was 10/10."

Cons:

  • "It was so dark that we used our phone lights to try to make it better."
  • "I didn't appreciate this tall gentleman who I don't know if he was a manager or not acknowledging every family except me and my husband and son whom we are African American."
  • "The service was terrible which was a surprise."
  • "Our food was cold, never was asked if we were okay or wanted refills."
  • "We waited over an hour and half to receive food that was cooked for about two minutes."
  • "We felt rushed and did not feel welcomed."
  • "our server was never available to check on our meal."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food here was phenomenal!!! Amazing fillet steak and the creamed spinach was also superb!"
  • "Our selections were seasoned and cooked to perfection."
  • "The steak was melt-in-your-mouth delicious as usual."
  • "The food was fabulous, steaks were perfect, sides very tasty."
  • "The food is good and what you would expect from a solid steakhouse."
  • "The food, as was the first time I visited, was on point. Steaks were cooked perfectly, the sides were tasty and a delicious dessert."
  • "The food is absolutely delicious!"

Cons:

  • "He order a New York steak and it was very chewy."
  • "the steaks were overcooked, not as requested."
  • "The steak was VERY burnt on the outside and almost raw in the inside (we ordered medium)."
  • "The popovers were burnt and the beef Wellington was overcooked."
  • "Chilean Sea Bass was not very good. Tough and stringy instead of soft and flaky."
  • "Lobster was inedible - tough, hard and impossible to chew."
  • "Steak was overcooked and tasteless and did not resemble a NY Strip."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The atmosphere is very warm and inviting."
  • "The place is really cool, and it’s surprisingly large inside."
  • "The atmosphere is warm and intimate."
  • "Once thing I love about this place is that it is very dim when you're inside. It gives that nightlife vibe at any time of day."
  • "I loved the ambience, plus the decor was very attractive."
  • "What a gem of a place! Cozy & inviting."
  • "Roots has that old school steak house feel with wood trim and a good mixture of tables and booths."

Cons:

  • "Went there NY ewe w a bigger party ... the place fell apart."
  • "Crying baby at table next to ours definitely did not add to the ambiance."
  • "A dining room that became unpleasantly loud."
  • "I’m going there to enjoy an upscale atmosphere and to enjoy a fancy night out with delicious food for an upscale price. It’s really disappointing when the people behind us are wearing hoodies."
  • "The restaurant was very dark, and quite loud; I struggled to hear people sitting directly next to me, or to read the menu."
  • "We were sitting outside in a odd area where we were facing the dumpsters."
  • "It was super dark and we felt in the way."

Value

Pros:

  • "Additionally the prices are worth the meal."
  • "Oh my goodness the food was very delicious and the prices are very reasonable."
  • "Food is beyond good. Lobster bites and filet is to die for."
  • "Price is a bit high, but if the food is good.... it's worth it to me."
  • "Nice wine list with reasonable prices for a steakhouse."
  • "The food was amazing. Steaks were cooked to perfection and all of the sides were fantastic."
  • "The food & service is excellent."

Cons:

  • "Admittedly a touch expensive for what it was - a single entree with no sides or additions was $35+."
  • "For the price of the food and drinks, I would've expected better service."
  • "Not worth the money at all πŸ‘Ž"
  • "Paid 700 dollars at our table of six to be put at a booth at a bar and not be able to hear each other."
  • "For the price we paid for lunch, I should have just went to capital grill where I would not have been disappointed and the service would have been way better."
  • "The valet guys try to pull a Fast one on you to charge you 20 dollars to park in a regular parking space in front of the location."
  • "I will not be back at this restaurant. I don’t mind paying for value and quality...this was NOT the place for that..."

Management

Pros:

  • "The manager asking how I was doing, was nice."
  • "We had multiple other managers come up to ensure everything was to our liking."
  • "Larry (Manager of the establishment) personally reached out and they genuinely cared about the experience we had."
  • "Larry is the only owner I know that went out of his way, delivered on his word and made it perfect!"
  • "There was a seating issue on one of our visits & the manager Larry went above & beyond to fix it."
  • "Management came over to congratulate us and provided a dessert on the house."
  • "Update - We returned to Roots after management followed up. The staff and food were fabulous."

Cons:

  • "The Maitre'D was not much better."
  • "We were then attacked and harassed by the manager to Get up from our table that second while we were waiting for our car service to arrive."
  • "Terrible service and management."
  • "I am writing this review is due to their incompetent valet service."
  • "I will never go back to a restaurant that I cannot trust."
  • "Given the price point I wish the management would have encouraged a more serene and befitting environment."
  • "The host was not nice nor accommodating."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.