Wood & Fire Neapolitan Style Pizza Reviews Summary

Category: Pizza restaurant

Address: 59 Marble Ave, Pleasantville, NY 10570, USA

Phone: +19147472611

Rating: 4.4
based on 151 reviews.

Outdoor Seating

Pros:

  • "They have an inclosed ‘outdoor’ area that I’m guessing is more open when it’s warmer."
  • "There is also a nice outdoor patio area for eating outside during the warmer months."
  • "Also, their outdoor seating set up is fantastic."
  • "Was able to sit outside with no wait or reservation."
  • "Wonderful outdoor seating area with heaters for the cooler weather."
  • "Outdoor seating in the summer is amazing."

Cons:

  • "Parking was challenging."

Service

Pros:

  • "Our service by Stefanie T. was excellent."
  • "Friendly service, great food and reasonable prices!"
  • "Love this place staff very nice and friendly."
  • "Great food, great people and awesome atmosphere."
  • "Our waiter was very attentive even on a busy Saturday Night."
  • "Responsive wait staff and wonderful service."
  • "The whole staff was warm and welcoming and they made sure our food was out quickly and was certifiably delicious."

Cons:

  • "Our server kept bumping and banging into people in our party as she was placing food at the table or attempting to refill drink glasses. No apologies were offered."
  • "Hostess very poor service (very rude and anti social)."
  • "The moment my friends and I arrived to the restaurant, the staff was very rude to us."
  • "The hostess was very cold."
  • "The host ignored me standing at the host stand and deliberately helped people that came in after me."
  • "Service was not terrible, but it wasn't good. The server checked on us once and took 20 minutes to bring the check after it was requested."
  • "The waitress from my last visit followed me outside to ask for more tip money."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The vegetarian thin crust pizza was good, but the pepperoni thick crust pizza was doughy and over charred."
  • "Literally the best fusilli with sausage and broccoli rabe you will ever have."
  • "Insanely good aracine (Sicilian rice balls: tomato, cheese, beef and rice) and amazing pizza (got the marble) with a great chew and flavorful base."
  • "The Roman and margherita pizzas are delicious! The spaghetti with pesto and shrimp was the best pesto I have tasted."
  • "I had the Linguine Nero, which was topped with one of the tastiest seafood medleys I've ever had."
  • "The pizza was amazing. The sauce was perfect. The crust was perfect."
  • "The pizza here is also great, but the tomato sauce on the Margherita has sometimes been a bit bland."

Cons:

  • "Had the chicken parm for 2 and was very disappointed."
  • "The mashed potatoes were not homemade, and the worst part is that you could tell."
  • "one of the worst most heinous pizzas i've had the displeasure of eating, and wretched ambiance to top it off."
  • "The pizza was a bit salty but so tasty."
  • "The pasta was over cooked."
  • "The food just lacks real Italian richness of flavor."
  • "Sadly pizza was lacking! We got the Sicilian style with pepperoni. Crust was awesome, pepperoni awesome; but cheese was really terrible :/."

Value for Money

Pros:

  • "Fairly priced and an overall good experience, would visit again."
  • "I appreciated that the salad and the pizza were loaded. Not necessarily cheap but a great value."
  • "But beside that a good meal at the right price you can ask for more."

Cons:

  • "They charge 9$ for zeppolis! like whatttt?!"
  • "Very small portions to boot. Not good value."
  • "Small portions for the price charged."
  • "The food is quite good, but overpriced."
  • "Food was a bit on the pricier side."
  • "20 DOLLARS FOR A 12 INCH PIZZA WITH 6 PIECES OF SPINACH AND SOME TRUFFLE OIL?"
  • "Food was OK at best and way overpriced."

Ambience

Pros:

  • "A place to bring a first date, or a lasting romance, I highly recommend this fine establishment."
  • "The atmosphere is big and open."
  • "Lovely atmosphere! A little over stimulating on a Friday night but you can tell it's a go-to hang out spot for young and old crowds."
  • "Higher end casual atmosphere in a trendy, rustic atmosphere."
  • "The atmosphere and ambience is both inviting and friendly."
  • "The vibe is lively."
  • "Restaurant and atmosphere is excellent."

Cons:

  • "The inside of the restaurant doesn't appeal to me - large TV's, very dark, modern furniture."
  • "The acoustics are not conducive to conversation."
  • "It's more of a club/bar atmosphere than a restaurant."
  • "Can get very noisy at peak hours on Friday and Saturday evenings."
  • "Atmosphere was not conducive to enjoying the company of others in our party."
  • "I found the environment very noisy/loud (72 decibels) due to multiple TV's, music in the background, and no sound barriers."
  • "It was over crowded and tables too close, not conforming with covid guidelines."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.