Amor Loco Reviews Summary

Category: Mexican restaurant New York

Address: 134 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036, USA

Phone: +19172615650

Rating: 4.3
based on 147 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "Friendly staff, excellent service."
  • "Our first waitress was really nice."
  • "Our server Antonella was super friendly and attentive."
  • "The service was very good and our server Victoria was delightful!"
  • "The staff was super friendly."
  • "The attendants who looked after us upstairs were super lovely and attentive."
  • "GREAT SERVICE !!!! Truly deserving of 5 stars."

Cons:

  • "Service is extremely slow."
  • "The waitress was so so rude!"
  • "I expected with the emptiness to get good quick service, but that was far from the scenario."
  • "When after waiting a long time and you finally have to go to the bar yourself for a drink and water refill, things are not going well."
  • "I can see why people complain about the service attitude."
  • "We weren't acknowledged for 20 minutes before we left with nothing but water in our bellies."
  • "Very poor service."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "All of the food was delicious and considering that it's so close to broadway the prices were pretty affordable!"
  • "The Birria tacos, get them get them get them! The atmosphere, love."
  • "The food was absolutely mind blowing and the service was super fast and kind."
  • "Loved the carne asada tacos, Baja fish tacos, and chicken quesadilla, as well as the drinks."
  • "The food was AMAZING - i got the breakfast burrito and it was so filling and delicious."
  • "The food was really chingona!"
  • "The food was excellent. The birria nachos and carnitas tacos were exceptional."

Cons:

  • "The food is horrible the place is small and crowded."
  • "Food was not that great though."
  • "The food needs much more improvement."
  • "Then they put us by a window that was open and we were freezing cold while eating the food."
  • "The food is really bad here, almost like cafeteria food."
  • "The food, definitely not feeling it. I had shrimp tacos and my friend had the Championes taco."
  • "Their chicken and waffles straigt out of supermarket frozen food section."

Atmosphere & Decor

Pros:

  • "The atmosphere is great the music gets you moving and the art / decor is very relaxing."
  • "Vibes are immaculate, music is great."
  • "Honestly one of the cutest places that I have been to by far in the city."
  • "The decor was very chic with great backdrops for top notch photos."
  • "It’s a Latino vibe which I personally love, the music they were playing was great."
  • "The music was fantastic."
  • "The decor inside and outside is very girly, fun, and festive with loads of pink ambient lighting."

Cons:

  • "Music a bit too loud for date night though."
  • "The place is loud, the food is mediocre, and they serve it too quickly - you cannot enjoy starters before mains."
  • "We were seated and waited in the extremely noisy yet mostly empty bar."
  • "This was the worst brunch experience of my life. I would not recommend this place to anyone ever."
  • "The ambiance is cheerful."
  • "Vibe is great they even had a burlesque show definitely fun night."
  • "Good music selection of the Spanish/reggaeton variety but low volume so could barely hear over the loud talking of other customers."

Value

Pros:

  • "If you're looking for a place that's very reasonable (quite a rarity in NYC, no less near Times Square) and one that has great food and drinks then this is the way to go."
  • "Place is absolutely affordable for New York standards."
  • "Price will be cheapest of my trip so far, just over $30 tip included ($24 for the food plus tax and $8 tip)."
  • "The Birria tacos are good but very over-priced."
  • "Being 18 and 20 for tacos, not worth the price at all."
  • "The drinks were great as well."
  • "The drinks were delicious and they were very generous with the alcohol."

Cons:

  • "Drinks have like no booze."
  • "Their soft drinks completely water down."
  • "I was charged $30 for two pieces of bread that measured about 3 inches by 2 1/2 inches wide."
  • "This place is very overpriced!! Not worth the over $400.00 spend there."
  • "25% tip on ticket was added and they have the audacity to suggest additional 7 to 10% more."
  • "Drinks were okay at best. Pretty pricey."
  • "Don't waste your money."

Drinks

Pros:

  • "The drinks were amazing, we all loved La Llorona, a mezcal drink that was so tasty."
  • "Margaritas are soooo goood also!"
  • "The margarita. It was one of the best I've had anywhere."
  • "But the passionfruit margarita stole the show."
  • "The passionfruit margarita one of the best margaritas I've ever had!!!"
  • "BABY THOSE DRINKS…BOMB. And STRONG lol we went on the weekend for the bottomless cocktails."
  • "I order a spicy margarita 🌢 and a mushroom tacos gluten free, sincerely a fell in love ❀️‍πŸ”₯"

Cons:

  • "I also ordered a skinny margarita but it definitely wasn’t made skinny - it tasted insanely sweet and I couldn’t even finish it."
  • "The guacamole arrives and it’s incredibly salty; from the chips to the actual guacamole."
  • "The guacamole was way too spicy."
  • "The girl who brought out the drinks had the worst attitude."
  • "Drinks were good, but came after 20 minutes on an empty Saturday night."
  • "Drink was delicious."
  • "The cheese quesadilla was soooo good. Honestly, the best food we've had in NYC since we've been here this week."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.