"The pizza is as perfect of a 'NY' slice as your can possibly get. These slices are amazing super crunchy lil burn on the bottom."
"The pizza at Joe's is simply divine. The crust is thin and crispy, the sauce is tangy and flavorful, and the cheese is gooey and melted."
"This just might be the best slice of cheese pizza I’ve ever had... the crust is so thin but crispy and you can hear the CRUNCH when you take a bite."
"The pizza here is delicious... Out of the pizza spots we visited will in town this place is definitely top 5 for me."
"Nothing beats a fresh slice of Joe’s pizza."
"The pizza slices at Joe’s are huge! They’re served hot, fresh, and full of flavor."
"For an authentic nyc slice, Joe’s Pizza is one of the best!"
Cons:
"Without a doubt some of the worst pizza I've ever had the displeasure of eating."
"It was a little cold and not as crispy as I expected."
"We didn't find the pizza flavourful at all."
"The sauce was missing salt and there was very little cheese on the slices."
"The mozzarella pizza has the strangest mozzarella texture. It's dry cheese. Bone dry."
"The pizza sauce tasted so off, like it was some store bought generic sauce."
"The pizza itself is not a redeeming factor. It's dripping with grease, and the sauce tastes weird."
Service
Pros:
"Too busy but the service was quick."
"Always a line for a reason! Cash only."
"Although the line was almost out the door, the service was pretty quick."
"Joe’s was packed, yet despite a line snaking out the front door, a hurried and efficient process meant a wait of only a few minutes."
"The staff are super friendly and old school and I think the service is fast."
"They are quick and the pizza is hot, very fast pace which is good if you are looking for something on the go."
"Service is fast and turn over rapid, so don’t worry about a queue out the door - it moves quick."
Cons:
"The guy at the front taking orders was so unnecessarily rude to everyone that came to support this establishment."
"It was so busy I don't think they could take the time to make the best version of their pizza."
"Came to this pizza store with high expectations thinking it was going to be out of this world... The pizza is mediocre at best."
"Then beggars come and harass you in the shop."
"Service was poor and the guy was rude."
"Pizza is always good... but the service just goes down and they weren't even busy."
"I asked the guy if he could clean the slicer when giving me the slice... horrible customer service overall not even sanitary with their tools nor their hands."
Price
Pros:
"I went here a few years ago and the pizza was only $2.99 however now they are about $4.50."
"The prices are incredibly reasonable."
"Great slice for $3 in the West Village - be warned it gets crowded on Saturday night and you may have to wait 15 or 20 minutes in line."
"Cheap and delicious, the pizza here will definitely satisfy your craving."
"The price was great for an ideal lunch."
"The slices are pretty cheap for its flavour and size, around $3 a slice for a Magherita."
"Not expensive and taste good."
Cons:
"$4 for a slice of pizza. Sooooooooo ridiculous."
"Not worth the price or hype. I paid over $40 with delivery for a single pizza."
"It’s more expensive than the other NY pizza but it’s so good that you don’t care!"
"Price of the slices went up and the quality of service went down."
"This place charges $4 per slice, were 99 cent pizzas are absolutely delicious."
"Really pricey for typical pizza."
"The price per slice has gotten a bit high, at $5 for a pepperoni slice, $5 for a Sicilian slice, and $3 for a soda."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"Wanting to optimize our experience my friend and I headed to the original Greenwich location after a few beers, reveling in the village’s boisterous Friday night atmosphere."
"Pizza ambiance energy .. everything is perfect you can order a slice or whole pizza it's all tasty and worth it."
"Good pizza & very nice atmosphere 👌 took my grandson there because he wanted to see where spider man work!"
"It's a classic New York-style place with a cool atmosphere."
"The restaurant is located in the heart of Greenwich Village, so you can expect a lively and fun atmosphere."
"Beautiful pizza from a genuinely old skool unpretentious pizza joint."
"The space has an old school vibe, with limited variety but good pies."
Cons:
"Leaving 3 stars because the inside of the spot is so dingy, it's really just purely for takeout."
"The actual restaurant is small so it did feel a bit crowded with the amount of people inside."
"Ambiance was Santa Con drunks on the downslope...but it sure is popular."
"The restaurant is dirty and it's too small for the volume of people that enter at a time."
"We ate slices surrounded by half a dozen overflowing garbage bags."
"The place is usually crowded with small room to eat inside."
"It wasn’t worth the trek across town to come here."
Payment Options
Pros:
"Always a line for a reason! Cash only."
"Cash only but has an ATM outside and is usually packed with people."
"The place is cash only so remember to bring cash."
"It’s open till about 4am. I bring my kids now… It’s fresh, hot, super thin crust with fresh sauce."
"a NYC STAPLE. MUST BRING CASH. There’s an ATM right outside but there are always a ton of people by the entrance and in line, so plan ahead and bring your cash."
"It’s cash only place so make sure to bring cash. Worse case scenario there’s a ATM outside of the establishment."
"It is cash only, so be prepared."
Cons:
"The pizza was wonderful it was really busy and accepted only cash but it was 💯percent worth it."
"I took out one star because they only take cash."
"Keep in mind this place only takes cash!"
"The place was cash only so make sure you have cash if you're planning to go."
"First, they're cash only."
"This place is cash only at about $4 a slice of their classic pizza."
"Costlier than others and only cash is accepted which is another let down."