Slattery's Midtown Pub Reviews Summary

Category: Bar New York

Address: 8 E 36th St, New York, NY 10016, USA

Phone: +12126836444

Rating: 4.3
based on 142 reviews.

Space and Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The private room upstairs is spacious with plenty of seating."
  • "The atmosphere was wonderful."
  • "The atmosphere was laid back and I actually felt comfortable."
  • "It felt safe and very diverse. A non prejudice atmosphere."
  • "Slattery's has TONS of TVs (upstairs and downstairs) and the unpretentious environment makes it one of the best places in the city to watch a game."
  • "Went here for an event on the second floor. Great space."
  • "The balcony on the second floor added a great touch, giving us the option to go outdoors, while still having the option to stay indoors- all within the privacy of our own party space."

Cons:

  • "The upstairs though was pretty devoid of personality."
  • "As a bar, Slattery's is as good as many and better than some, however, I have been to 'dance' parties at this bar, where the upstairs 'party room' is used with a Deejay, and I have to say that the party room is not conducive to a dance party."
  • "The upstairs was not closed off so there were many people coming upstairs that I did not know and had to ask them to leave because it was a private event."

Service

Pros:

  • "The staff was very attentive and the owner went above and beyond for us!"
  • "Staff were really attentive."
  • "The staff always make you feel like family."
  • "All the staff were vet friendly and provided great service."
  • "Waitress was pleasant and attentive."
  • "We're always welcomed by a friendly staff."
  • "The staff was super friendly and service was great throughout the entire night."

Cons:

  • "Service was a little slow and inattentive, but understandable for trivia night."
  • "Service was borderline atrocious. Initial server gave us menus and never came back."
  • "Food was not replenished and the second bartender was aggressive and not very pleasant."
  • "Also, there was no bartender! We waited about 5-10 minutes then finally went next door."
  • "Unfortunately the communication between management and bartenders wasn’t great."
  • "Bartender blamed us for smoking... Refused to serve us because she blamed us for the smoke that came from outside."
  • "I'm sorry, but I'm incredibly frustrated. I go to Slattery's after a Sunday NFL game... the kitchen was closed."

Food and Drinks

Pros:

  • "They also have a decent menu of food items- I've only ordered from it once, but it was pretty solid pub food."
  • "The food was well prepared, hot and delicious."
  • "The teriyaki chicken was a HIT."
  • "The drinks were great, the food was really good."
  • "I had the Reuben burger which was perfect."
  • "The food was hot and delicious and the drinks were simply on point!"
  • "We loved the burgers, wings, fish & chips, burritos, nachos, to name a few."

Cons:

  • "The turkey burger was a frozen turkey Patty tossed on the grill to get grill marks. No flavor."
  • "Food wise, we only had the starter platter and it wasn't the best."
  • "The chicken fingers and mozzarella sticks are particularly flash-frozen in nature, so avoid those."
  • "I've found the food to be pretty stale."
  • "My friends chicken pesto sandwich didn't even have taste and was extremely hot. The pesto sauce was blend."
  • "Pub food was pretty standard."
  • "Short story: Drinks are expensive and disgusting."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.