Stout NYC Reviews Summary

Category: Bar New York

Address: 90 John St, New York, NY 10038, USA

Phone: +12122409122

Rating: 4.2
based on 151 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Food and drinks were good."
  • "Food fantastic (recommend the giant pretzel the size of my head)."
  • "The fries were so fresh and salted perfectly."
  • "The food was great as well."
  • "I had the Stout Burger with fries and it was really good."
  • "Their food is great, it is huge so there's always a place to sit, and the drinks are strong."
  • "The food is tasty and very reasonably priced for such an establishment."

Cons:

  • "The food was just average, ordered a burger with fries and even the fries where bad, over cooked and bland."
  • "The wings are breaded, gross."
  • "Pretty good food, but horrible service even during a slower time of day. 10 minutes to deliver drinks. 1 hour for burger."
  • "Ordered a NY strip medium-RARE, emphasizing the rare. Got a steak that was medium-WELL."
  • "Calamari also frozen. Tasts like chewy cheese like imitation lobster."
  • "The food is mediocre, the service is far worse."
  • "Pizza look and taste like lunchables pizza for kids. Sweet tomato sauce and bland cheese on paper dough bread."

Service

Pros:

  • "Wait staff were also extremely friendly and attentive, great atmosphere for the fights."
  • "Claire is absolutely phenomenal. We had our fair share of personal issues here last weekend and Claire calmly assessed the situation like a true professional!!"
  • "The staff is always friendly and accommodating."
  • "The entire staff is amazing."
  • "The service was great! The young women that took care of us was super attentive but not intrusive."
  • "Outstanding experience - friendly and swift staff."
  • "The Bartender Leann gave amazing service, was very welcoming and she made great drinks."

Cons:

  • "VERY LOUD! Couldn't even hear my partner talking to me and he was right next to me."
  • "The bouncer turned away a nice woman and her mother for no reason, along with several other people."
  • "Pretty good food, but horrible service even during a slower time of day. 10 minutes to deliver drinks. 1 hour for burger."
  • "We had to ask several times just for water and at least 3 times for a check."
  • "Sat for 10 minutes without being greeted, several servers walked past us texting on their phones ignoring us."
  • "The service was slow and the staff forgot our order multiple times."
  • "Service is fairly bad when they are busy."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "The aesthetic of the place immediately caught my eye and added to the overall experience."
  • "We felt welcomed and comfortable."
  • "Loved the low lighting and how the tables were arranged."
  • "Great place to watch the UFC PPV fights!"
  • "High ceiling seems to be elegant and fascinating and makes the atmosphere very comfortable."
  • "Great large space to have a Guinness!"
  • "It was a bit too loud, however, the energy of the game was exciting!!"

Cons:

  • "VERY LOUD! Couldn't even hear my partner talking to me and he was right next to me."
  • "Not the most kid friendly spot. It has tons of space."
  • "Too expensive for quality."
  • "It was VERY crowded when I got there on Friday evening... but it's a good spot."
  • "This is not really a place that you would want to go with your family as the music was super loud and was hard to talk to each other."
  • "There were many televisions everywhere, all of them were set to poker, the most boring thing to watch of all 'sports'."
  • "On big games, this place fills up pretty quickly to capacity and they stop letting people in."

Price

Pros:

  • "Crafts are only $7 a bottle which was surprising."
  • "Good food and beer specials."
  • "Prices are also reasonable which can be hard to come by in FIDI."

Cons:

  • "$10 pints of Guinness are a bit much, but it's Manhattan, whaddya expect..."
  • "Beers are city prices."
  • "Ketchup is an extra charge with your fries as you get one sauce per plate and mine already came with tartar sauce...weird."
  • "Too expensive for quality."
  • "Then I paid $17 for what 4-5 oz. Complete garbage."
  • "What I can not get past is the fact you charged me $1 for a few cubes of ice for my whiskey."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.