The Churchill Tavern Reviews Summary

Category: Bar New York

Address: 45 E 28th St, New York, NY 10016, USA

Phone: +16469227744

Rating: 4.3
based on 146 reviews.

Ambiance and Decor

Pros:

  • "This is a good-looking bar with nice ambiance, taking a step above a regular pub in my book."
  • "The Churchill is an excellent bar/restaurant. The owner is a former set designer and a Brit so the atmosphere really feels like an authenticate British pub."
  • "Pretty awesome watering hole / bar in midtown. Definitely has a good after work crowd. Went during Christmas time and the decor was amazing for the holidays."
  • "Superb atmosphere especially at Christmas."
  • "I really like the ambience and decor, it's a beautiful little pub with a great selection of beers."
  • "Lovely private places to sit, nicely dimly lit cozy corners."
  • "The dining area was very pleasantly decorated and lighted very nicely."

Cons:

  • "The pub was decorated beautifully but there was no atmosphere, no Christmas tunes and it all felt very rushed."
  • "Friday/Saturday nights get really really loud, you've been warned."
  • "The drinking area sounded like it had a great atmosphere but I had my back to the room."
  • "Very dark, and busy for The football."
  • "Nice place but dining inside, it's too dark to see ur food!"
  • "Upon arriving, we were greeted by a hostess who seemed uninterested and unwelcoming."
  • "We went here with high expectations of enjoying a delicious meal, drinks and a pleasant experience. But unfortunately, our experience with the hostess left us disappointed."

Service

Pros:

  • "The staff was super friendly and welcoming."
  • "Super attentive and helpful staff, great happy hour prices, and delicious food."
  • "The staff is extremely friendly."
  • "Service was fast and friendly."
  • "The servers are very attentive and catered to all our needs despite it being very busy."
  • "Service was competent, charming complete with a UK accent."
  • "The service is fast and friendly."

Cons:

  • "I really want to like this place - I really do, but the service really ruined our experience."
  • "The waitress was beyond rude."
  • "The server bartender could have been far more attentive otherwise it would be five stars."
  • "Service horrendous."
  • "The service is not very speedy, but the food and drinks are worth it."
  • "When we told the waitress, she rudely picked up the salad and then dropped off the bill without so much as a sympathetic word or apology."
  • "Service was great. Food was good if not great."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The beer was delicious too."
  • "The English pub classics like bangers and mash and the Meat and ale pies were excellent."
  • "Food was good, England style dishes."
  • "A fine English pub, with a fair amount of selection on tap, and enough food items to comfortably justify having dinner."
  • "Good selection of drinks and surprisingly tasty food."
  • "The food was HOT (thank you, Chef)! The meatballs were dense and tasty."
  • "My salad was good with big shrimp."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.