"Very friendly staff good beers on tap and really delicious wings."
"Bartender was awesome. Let us try a bunch of different beers as samples."
"The service is wonderful, and the food are breathtaking."
"Nolan and Chris just might be the best bartenders that NYC has to offer!"
"The staff was friendly and was able to let us sample a few of the beers as well."
"Friendly staff."
"The Irish gal behind the bar had great customer service."
Cons:
"Service was very mediocre."
"Service ruined this experience! No table service and bartenders didn't really seem interested in serving or have much beer knowledge!"
"Service was unfriendly and without a smile."
"Four people were in the bar and the bartender still managed to be pretentious."
"However the staff left a lot to be desired. One member was just very rude and unhelpful."
"The bartenders were impatient and rude."
"But the service is just so slow and the food take a while to come out."
Atmosphere and Vibe
Pros:
"The place has a laid back, cozy vibe, more like a small town pub, very different from other more tacky venues around the west end."
"Great atmosphere."
"Unpretentious atmosphere."
"Walking in here brought ideas of what a neighborhood bar should be. Lively, a large beer collection, and some energetic staff."
"Very chill place."
"It's a small, local bar with an amazing atmosphere and even better beer choice."
"This place has such a great atmosphere."
Cons:
"I'm really sad about how it has changed. It went from having tvs that listed the beers on tap and a charming new beer bell ritual to just another sports bar."
"Gets a little crowded at happy hour but usually thins out early."
"Can get really crowded."
"The music was very loud when I was there and we had to do some shouting just to be heard across the table."
"It can get crowded, and it's not a huge place. Can also get sort of dark in the winter."
"Very loud when the place is hopping."
"Can get a bit loud but the delicious beers make it worthwhile."
Food and Drinks
Pros:
"The pulled pork sandwich is great."
"Always have a good selection of beers from far and wide - including California, the craft beer capital."
"Fantastic craft beer bar with a unique and frequently rotating selection."
"The dinner menu is small but the spicy sausage is excellent, as are the home made chips."
"They also serve great quality classic pub cuisine."
"One of the best beer selections in the city. Always domestic craft beer."
"Had lots of awesome craft beers, from light to dark and all in between."
Cons:
"The unique thing was I want well done hamburger, and I received a medium well..."
"Last few times my mixed drinks were either pretty weak or overpriced."
"Food is decent but the drinks are not priced well for a good casual go to spot."
"The food tastes blah !!! In my opinion the street vendor food is better."
"The food was cold, and overpriced."
"We are also fried pickles fans but unfortunately their pickles were lacking."
"Worst food ever, burger was a pre fab patty, fries and wings burnt in old oil."
Pricing and Value
Pros:
"We thought the prices for the location were very reasonable and the food was lovely."
"All beers always 5 dollars."
"With beer prices creeping up to the $8 a pint mark, this Hell's Kitchen watering hole keeps things real with plenty of pints for $5."
"Their pints are super affordable and their happy hour are between 4:20PM and 5:20PM is great with every pint of beer for $4."
"Great prices on said beers, ESPECIALLY for New York."
"They are really good prices, mostly at only $5."
"This beautiful bar serves up hard to find American craft beer – they pour sample-sized servings for $5 each, so you can try them all."
Cons:
"Burger was $13.95 plus $1 for cheese and $2 to get side salad or sweet potato fries or onion rings."
"The food there is very good although a bit pricey."
"Some months have weaker beers than others, and the food is a bit on the expensive side for what you're being served."
"The drinks were horrible and the food is what everyone claims to be 'bar food.'"