PizzArte Reviews Summary

Category: Italian restaurant New York

Address: 69 W 55th St, New York, NY 10019, USA

Phone: +12122473936

Rating: 4.5
based on 256 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The ingredients were fresh and the toppings were delicious."
  • "Amazing gluten free pizza made in hot brick oven."
  • "The food is authentic Italian…the fettuccine bolognese was one of the best we have ever had and the Neopolitan style pizza is incredible."
  • "Delicious Italian food with inspiration drawn from Napoli staples."
  • "The pizzas and homemade pastas were phenomenal; better than many in Naples itself."
  • "Really genuine Italian pizza, great dough mix, yummy and juicy mozzarella and well picked tomatoes."
  • "The food was the best I’ve ever had and was made very fast and very fresh!"

Cons:

  • "I just ordered take-out pizza. VERY disappointed. The pizza is one size - small - and it's $20+ dollars! When I brought it home, the dough was soggy and chewy."
  • "The dough was well made but bland, almost tasteless toppings straight out of the jar/canned slices of black olives, mushrooms and artichokes made it soggy and watery very fast."
  • "Lasagna dish had no traces of meat whatsoever and was basically boiled sheets of pasta with bland tomato sauce and some cheese sprinkled on top. ZERO meat in there, or egg for that matter."
  • "The calamari was completely bland, no seasoning in the batter or added afterwards."
  • "The pizza was a huge disappointment."
  • "Pizza was pretty flavorless considering the ingredients."
  • "It was in one word gross. $22 per pie on average got you a poorly seasoned and seriously soggy personal sized pizza that left a lot to be desired."

Service

Pros:

  • "Service was prompt and excellent."
  • "Great food and excellent service. Staff are extremely helpful and offer suggestions on wine or food if needed."
  • "Awesome service with an extremely friendly boss (owner?) who really cares about the mood of his customers."
  • "The service was amazing, very warm and so friendly!"
  • "Service was warm, friendly, and helpful. Most spoke Italian as their native language."
  • "Service was excellent and staff was very inviting."
  • "The customer service was impeccable."

Cons:

  • "The man who took my order was also grumpy and not at all welcoming."
  • "However, the service was really slow."
  • "The server was quite rude though."
  • "We did not receive the best service."
  • "The hostesses had no personality and had no communication."
  • "The waiter never checked on us except to bring the check and take it."
  • "Our waiter was MIA throughout the majority of our meal."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "Thank you so much for fantastic atmosphere and delicious food."
  • "A cozy interior and not much room at the bar for knees."
  • "The atmosphere of the restaurant is amazing as well."
  • "Some cute art on the walls and felt like eating on a small gallery."
  • "Very cute restaurant in midtown with art on the walls, most of which is for sale."
  • "Inside the restaurant is cozy, clean, and comfortable."
  • "The atmosphere was very modern and the restaurant was decorated very nice."

Cons:

  • "Rather cozy downstairs and sometimes noisy in the upper area, but all good."
  • "Nobody questioned why we left most of our food."
  • "Pizza was a little sloppy."
  • "The place was so small everything was perfect."
  • "There is a musty/ moldy smell downstairs but once we were upstairs we didn’t smell it."
  • "Our upstairs dining area was extremely loud."
  • "Can't fault the food, but the experience (as a single diner, seated at the bar) was poor."

Value

Pros:

  • "The price was more than fair considering the level of food and service."
  • "Good wine selection and good enough wine quality."
  • "Really good value for the quality."
  • "The food is great and not that expensive."
  • "Also moderately priced for such great quality and location."
  • "Reasonably priced by NY standards."
  • "The prices reasonable."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.