Perry St Reviews Summary

Category: American restaurant New York

Address: 176 Perry St, New York, NY 10014, USA

Phone: +12123521900

Rating: 4.5
based on 129 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The cocktails were outstanding, and the food, even more amazing."
  • "I loved all of them especially the lobster and the crispy tuna with tingly sensation."
  • "The raw tuna coated with japanese cracker is delicious."
  • "Duck was cooked perfectly."
  • "The butter poached lobster is also good."
  • "The sashimi for a starter cut like butter and was so smooth."
  • "The truffle brie was phenomenal and perfect to share for the table."

Cons:

  • "Somehow the whole package doesn't quite come together in this reviewers opinion."
  • "Food is average."
  • "Another dish that arrived at our table after being highly touted, but just didn’t do it for us."
  • "Food was well prepared, excepting the lobster, but lacking in flavor."
  • "Not all the dishes were seasoned enough which was kind of disappointing."
  • "Squash soup was good but lobster entree was inedible - like bubble gum."
  • "The tuna burger was pretty bland."

Service

Pros:

  • "Loved the service and ambiance."
  • "You clearly continue to take pride in your culinary craft, and hospitality."
  • "Great service and love how they keep changing the utensils after each course."
  • "Service was great."
  • "Henry was the most attentive and pleasant server and made our dining experience memorable."
  • "The service is amazing and everything is considered."
  • "Staff was very attentive and helpful."

Cons:

  • "Get ready for an over $400 check for 2. Def. not worth it."
  • "We spent $200 per person for the 4 courses tasting menu they highly recommended last night and they told us ‘sorry we need the table for the next round guests’ when we were there 2 and half hours with 4 courses and still having the dessert."
  • "Service was ok, missed a few empty glasses of water until called out."
  • "After that he never came by to ask us how the food was or if everything is OK."
  • "No service. The waitress threw the check."
  • "Super disappointed to be treated like an any customer while I am ordering from this restaurant twice a week for the past 6 years!"
  • "The problem is the service. Appetizers come at blazing speed and on both occasions we needed to tell them to slow service down."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "Romantic, refined contemporary American cuisine in a quiet spot overlooking the West Side Highway."
  • "Beautiful ambiance, great service and amazing food."
  • "A gorgeous ambiance, great service, and very good food created the perfect date night."
  • "Gorgeous food in a sleek, minimalist space!"
  • "The vibe is inviting and upscale but not stuffy."
  • "Great ambiance, beautiful yet simple decor."
  • "Amazing ambiance on a peaceful street by the west side highway."

Cons:

  • "The one downside is that it's so far from any subway that it's a long walk when it's cold or raining."
  • "Feels like a fancy business hotel lobby."
  • "Sadly, it wasn’t that memorable."
  • "Bland decor."
  • "I couldn't quite shake the airport lounge vibe."
  • "The restaurant is spacious and white, making it seem a bit cold and sparse in the light of day."
  • "It was a little noisy eating next to the highway every time the light turned green, LOL."

Value

Pros:

  • "Less expensive than expected."
  • "Pricey, but the food and service were great."
  • "The food equals the price."
  • "Great ambiance, delicious, high quality food at affordable prices and excellent service."
  • "You will be spending a bit more but you are also getting what you pay for!"
  • "Yes, the meal is darn expensive, but it's one of the only expensive meals where I've ever felt it was an experience worth paying for."
  • "You get what you pay for."

Cons:

  • "Get ready for an over $400 check for 2. Def. not worth it."
  • "Every dish was on point. It was great. I really loved the desserts and salmon! But I think you can try similar food in cheaper price. Kind of overpriced i think."
  • "For the price.... There are so many great restaurants in the west village I would feel like returning would be a waste of time and money."
  • "Tasty food but very small portions."
  • "We paid $290 in total including tips per person. The wine paring is at $68 but it’s not so great."
  • "4 people (with 1 child), $500 with tip. Unacceptable for the quality."
  • "Disappointing for the price, but still good."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.