New York Luncheonette Reviews Summary

Atmosphere & Location

Pros:

• "Perfectly 'New York' luncheonette!"
• "They still exist!!! No fuss, down to earth solid NY diner - clean, reasonable."
• "Right in the Waldorf Astoria Hotel, Rockefeller Center and St. Patrick's Cathedral neighborhood."
• "What a great place to eat. Atmosphere is casual and the staff was great!"
• "Really sweet NYC neighborhood Mom & Pop spot."
• "I enjoyed the old school ambience of the restaurant."
• "Such a cute little New York Pl., so classic."

Cons:

• "The restaurant was disgustingly dirty and unkempt."
• "Tiny bugs flying onto my breakfast."
• "Overcrowded, overpriced, adequate food. Small portions for breakfast."
• "You're not long for this neighborhood, if you don't do salad well."
• "The atmosphere was plesent but quite small but cozy."
• "The atmosphere was an ear-piercing nightmare, filled with incessant kids' cries."
• "Seating is close, so any loud group makes it a loud experience for everyone else."

Service

Pros:

• "The service is outstanding, and they're generous with the coffee refills."
• "Waiters are all very friendly and courteous."
• "Service was fast."
• "Excellent service, one of the most efficient kitchens I've ever seen."
• "The service was quick and attentive."
• "Very friendly service, very attentive."
• "Service is fantastic all the staff are very friendly."

Cons:

• "When we arrived there, the waiter was pressurizing us to order the food as soon as we sat down."
• "Additionally the staff was super rude!"
• "Customer service was not this guy's strong suit!"
• "He demanded me to give him a tip saying Sir, you didn't pay the service charge."
• "Never saw the waiter again. Never asked about my food or if I needed anything else like a refill or water."
• "My server's apathetic demeanor and disdainful looks added insult to injury."
• "Waiters\waitreses just want you in and out as quickly as possible."

Food Quality

Pros:

• "Food really good quality."
• "Wonderful food."
• "The food was so good, prices were reasonable."
• "Loove the food, big serving plates and delicious, great price."
• "Quality food and service."
• "The food is delicious great pricing, service is top notch."
• "The French Toast was delicious and my eggs were cooked to perfection."