Amore Pizza Reviews Summary

Quality of Pizza

Pros:

• "Pizza taste great when chowed on the spot."
• "This Pizza is just a simple work of art."
• "Love love love their pizza. I would put it up against ANY pizza place in NYC in a taste test."
• "Definitely the best pizza in New York."
• "The cheese was perfection, the sauce was just right, the crust nice and crispy."
• "The absolute BEST pizza, hands-down."
• "The Best New York Style Pizza! I had onion and sausage toppings and they were fresh and chunky!"

Cons:

• "The pizza was under cooked, all the toppings was still cold."
• "Nasty, soggy, chewy pizza."
• "Pizza was cold then reheated tasted stale."
• "The pizza was very greasy. I had to pat down my slices with a napkin because there was just entire sections with puddles of grease."
• "Paper thin dough with grease it's not really sauce or cheese."
• "I GOT TERRIBLE FOOD POISONING FROM THIS PLACE. NOT CLEAN."
• "The pizza is MEDIOCRE however the last 4 times I been for pickup they practically burn the pizza."

Customer Service

Pros:

• "Got a full pizza to go. I believe the owner was at the counter. She was very pleasant."
• "They are always friendly and they remember us."
• "People working there make you feel right at home, our pie never leaves the pizzeria!"
• "The staff was friendly, amazing, and had great recommendations to do around town for us visiting."
• "The customer service was great! The guys and the lady behind the counter are a whole vibe and super sweet!"
• "The people who run this spot are good honest people."
• "I love the pizza here been coming here since I was a kid... Each time that I have gone after work I’ve always seen all employees with mask on and very respectful."

Cons:

• "Yes, the place is nothing to brag about the employees are rude but who cares the Pizza is AWESOME!!!"
• "Pizza is good but customer service is below par."
• "The guy serving my pizza was rude and didn't wear gloves."
• "Pizza is really good. The guy who runs the business is super unprofessional and rude."
• "Great food but horrible staff."
• "The staff seem pretty rude here to each other. Their attitude in general is not good at all."
• "The new owner, however, is not a pleasant person."

Atmosphere and Decor

Pros:

• "Pizza is amazing here!... TV is always on with soccer matches so you can enjoy some sports while you eat. Plenty of parking in the lot."
• "This is the type of Pizza joint that made Pizza famous in America."
• "It’s a bare bones, no frills pizzeria that just dishes out consistently quality pizza for years."
• "This is the epitome of a classic pizza joint."
• "The place is not flashy, the decor is that of an old school NYC pizzeria."
• "Decor...well I don't go there to look at pictures, I go there to eat pizza."
• "Everyone in Flushing knows Amore's is the best NY slice in the city."

Cons:

• "The dining area is completely outdated and looks worse than a lot of typical Chinese restaurants."
• "It's a little small so sometimes can be crowded."
• "I ended up seeing a roach on the table."
• "The layout is so small, there is no organization at the counter so everyone is just standing in front if you are trying to order."
• "They have 8 - 9 tables to sit but it's a tight/narrow spot so don't expect to be walkin around."
• "Table was dirty! My 7 year old started to clean the table."
• "Horrible! No health grade posted."

Value and Convenience

Pros:

• "The price was moderate and well worth the price."
• "A slice reg is 3.00. If you get a pie it's reasonable."
• "Prices are good and pizza is delicious 🍕 🍕 🍕"
• "Plenty of parking."
• "Prices are very reasonable and competitive with other places."
• "Perfect New York Pizza - Perfect New York Price!"
• "Everyone in Flushing knows Amore's is the best NY slice in the city."

Cons:

• "They only accept cash though. No credit card."
• "Unfortunately, they don't accept credit or debit cards, so remember to bring cash before you come."
• "Please note they are so old school they don't take credit ONLY CASH."
• "They only take cash."
• "The only downside is that you have to bring cash, they don't take any other payment."
• "Payed 10 dollars for 2 pepperoni slices."
• "Not enough cheese for $3.25. in fact, even at $3 there's still not enough cheese."