Weckerly’s Ice Cream Reviews Summary

Service

Pros:

• "Angelique was so friendly and lovely!"
• "The staff is super nice."
• "Locally sourced ingredients, extremely friendly service and a very clean store."
• "Also very friendly gentlemen who offered to cut the sandwiches in half so my friend and I could share."
• "The staff are so friendly and welcoming."
• "The owner was very friendly and patient as I had small kids with me."
• "Staff is always nice and friendly."

Cons:

• "The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars is because the woman who worked at the counter was, no offense, kinda rude."
• "Since the change of ownership service has become less friendly which is disappointing."
• "The woman scooping the ice cream into my cone in the back was moving at a sloth's pace."
• "The staff was barely awake."
• "This place was not inviting nor welcoming."
• "Sandwiches are not as consistent as before."
• "I was really disappointed in the low quality of this extremely overpriced ice cream."

Ice Cream Quality

Pros:

• "Their ice cream flavors are genius and so unique with new flavors constantly being introduced to the menu."
• "They even have vegan chocolate and peanut butter sorbet!!"
• "The ice cream is out of this world."
• "The unique flavors are incredibly delicious."
• "Everything Weckerly's makes tastes outstanding and fresh."
• "The flavors are so rich and full, every lick is like the first taste, never too cold, never bland."
• "Everything is made from scratch (waffle cones, cookies for their ice cream sandwiches, etc) and is truly magnificent."

Cons:

• "The ice cream sandwich I had, the black and white, was awful."
• "Ice cream was icy and seemed freezer burnt."
• "Their Icecream isn't as thick as I like or strong enough in flavor."
• "The ice cream was boring & terrible."
• "I think they change the recipe for the vainilla pints, it tasted like cold water with vainilla flavoring."
• "Ice cream sandwiches were meh. Nothing special."
• "Really disappointed after how hyped up this place was. The texture was kind of crystalized, not very creamy."

Value

Pros:

• "Prices are fair."
• "This place never disappoints."
• "It's definitely on the expensive side but is completely worth it."
• "Best Ice Cream I've ever had in my life."
• "The prices are pretty cheap."
• "High quality ice cream and super friendly service!"
• "They definitely have unique flavors and good options."

Cons:

• "Felt prices were a tad inflated."
• "For the price I believe you should get more than one small scoop."
• "Expensive for the size."
• "It was overpriced."
• "Pint prices have gone from $10 to $13 but still worth it."
• "I was really disappointed in the low quality of this extremely overpriced ice cream."
• "Wish there was more seating."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "We always take out of town guests here to try their ice cream sandwiches after dinner."
• "If you're in the area, it's a must stop!"
• "This is the 2nd best ice cream i've tried in Philly."
• "Small, quaint ice cream shop with interesting ice cream flavors."
• "A wonderful little neighborhood ice cream shop right in the middle of Fishtown."
• "A very clean store."
• "This cute little ice cream shop is worth the wait."

Cons:

• "There was very little space to form a line and the crowd kept amassing."
• "Occasional disappointment when they dont have your favorite flavors or when they sell out quickly."
• "Yeah, the flavors are tasty, but, just like most other ice creams, there's never enough add-ins."
• "It was good but I thought there would be more flavors."
• "Very limited, unique flavors (e.g. mint with rosemary and honey). Very few traditional flavors."
• "They don’t always have the flavors that they have on the website they’re very limited to flavors."
• "There isn't a lot of space inside and there's only one bench to sit on outside."