"Our server, John gave us outstanding service and the entire staff was friendly."
"Our server Jake was very knowledgeable about the menu and very attentive without being intrusive."
"Yanni was my server both days and was incredibly kind and attentive."
"Our waitress was amazing! She knew the menu like the back of her hand."
"The service is attentive and the portion size is good."
"Jenny was our server (we lucked out!), she had the best recommendations for dishes!"
"From the server to the manager we felt very well taken care of."
Cons:
"The manager lady was so rude! She rolled her eyes after speaking to my table as if WE were in the wrong!"
"Our reservation was at 9, it was 9:30 and all we had was two glasses of water."
"Service was very slow and wasn't impressed with the 'summer' menu."
"The hospitality wasn’t at the level that I’d expect from 1 Hotel."
"We had to ask twice and they finally threw us to a table and said take it or leave it, with a condescending attitude."
"I was hard pressed to identify a manager to whom I could complain."
"Service was slow."
Food Quality
Pros:
"The food was simply amazing!"
"All the dishes were amazing flavorful and delicious."
"The food was delicious, especially the oven roasted chicken and the pesto pasta."
"Hard to describe how good the food is."
"The halibut was the best my wife had ever had."
"Food was amazing 👏🏼 very tasty and fresh."
"Each dish we ordered was delicious."
Cons:
"There were literally five 1/2 inch square pieces of 'meat' in a child sized bowl of spaghetti like pasta with white sauce."
"The food looked great. The taste on the other hand ranged super salty to bland."
"Was not a fan of the oysters as they didn’t taste fresh."
"The coffee wasn't good!"
"Scallops were served over an unappealing, sweetened purple (?) sauce; fries were too salty; broccolini was bland; and 'crispy Brussels sprouts' were mushy."
"The food is generally good if not a little unimaginative."
"Ordered the halibut but I got monkfish with a side of confusion. Taste was very bland."
Ambiance and Setting
Pros:
"The decor is nice and the restaurant has nice views of lower Manhattan."
"We sat by the window and got to see the BK bridge at night, it was beautiful."
"Beautiful, idyllic setting in the middle of Brooklyn Bridge Park."
"An incredibly beautiful venue right in the heart of Brooklyn Bridge Park."
"The atmosphere is very soft and cozy w/fantastic views by the water."
"It was a little hard to get to from the train, but I would definitely come back for the setting alone."
"The Osprey is a beautiful restaurant located in Brooklyn Bridge Park!"
Cons:
"There was definitely a lack of class (children running around even hitting my table at all times)."
"The only confusing part was getting in the restaurant."
"However the hospitality wasn’t at the level that I’d expect from 1 Hotel."
"First the claims about amazing views is false. You can barely see the bridge or anything from the restaurant."
"The restrooms are a little out of the way and they are open to all sexual orientations. I found that quite uncomfortable."
"If you're sitting inside at the dinner tables, all you see is the bottom of the Brooklyn Bridge, not the whole bridge as is pictured in their advertisements."
"Really nice decor, however we dined inside and didn't like the fact that their staff were talking loudly near the bar area."