The Barley Beach House Reviews Summary

Category: American restaurant Rye, New York

Address: 95 Dearborn Ave, Rye, NY 10580, USA

Phone: +19144815505

Rating: 4.2
based on 123 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "We ordered the New England lobster roll (delicious), the paella (delicious), fish tacos (delicious), the chicken cobb salad (delicious) and fajitas... everything was a hit!"
  • "The food was excellent, as well as pretty decently priced for the quality and location."
  • "But all food was delicious! The French Onions Soup is soooo tasty, a must try."
  • "The tuna BLT was one of the best sandwiches I've had."
  • "Food tasted great."
  • "The CT Lobeter Rolls were delicious."
  • "The food is fresh and amazing!"

Cons:

  • "Fish over cooked, fries limp and soggy."
  • "Needless to say they were the driest tacos I have ever had."
  • "The steak was very bland and simple."
  • "Paella was good but could use a little spicing up."
  • "The food was portioned very small and for the price it was extremely too high."
  • "The food was bad."
  • "Fig flatbread was a joke - small and tasteless."

Service

Pros:

  • "What a great experience my family had this past weekend!"
  • "Service is a tad slow but there is no better place to wait!"
  • "The staff catered to our every need until the wee hours of the morning."
  • "Staff was really nice, welcoming, very accommodating, super friendly."
  • "We had an amazing lunch with amazing service."
  • "Every time I come the service and staff are just top notch!"
  • "The service was outstanding!!"

Cons:

  • "Very disappointed with the hostess and management."
  • "No server came to the table after that after passing by several times over 15 minutes."
  • "SLOWEST SERVICE I have ever experienced."
  • "No respect for people with kids."
  • "Our drinks took forever to arrive and also forgot a drink… we had to ask the waiter again for my lemonade."
  • "Service is painfully slow and the food sub-par."
  • "The service was terrible and inattentive and the food was not good and in fact made us sick!"

Ambiance and Location

Pros:

  • "Such a beautiful spot."
  • "It's on the beach so the views from anywhere u sit are wonderful!"
  • "Great views of the LI Sound and a lovely atmosphere."
  • "Nice place with a great view!"
  • "The view and space are beautiful."
  • "Sitting outside staring out into the ocean on a clear night is beautiful as always."
  • "The setting is lovely. Breezy patio on the beach."

Cons:

  • "There are 2 single bathrooms for the entire restaurant, so there’s always a line."
  • "place is overpriced and filthy!! BATHROOMS ARE Repulsive."
  • "The outside veranda is congested with the large umbrellas and ugly tables & chairs."
  • "Also, the bathroom was absolutely DISGUSTING."
  • "The lobster roll was a mushy mess with zero tail meat all claw meat and looked like it might have been pre frozen."
  • "The buffet had very limited options."
  • "Very crowded and very noisy. Slow service."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.