Mangiamo Pizza Restaurant & Catering Reviews Summary

Category: Restaurant Paramus, New Jersey

Address: 501 NJ-17, Paramus, NJ 07652, USA

Phone: +12012250555

Rating: 4.2
based on 168 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The pizza is delicious and the desserts are even better!"
  • "The Chicken Francese... was delicious the white wine sauce was great."
  • "The amazing cheesy pizza and the creamy pasta was amazing!!"
  • "Both were so amazing and I’ll be talking about our meal all the way home."
  • "The chicken parm and garlic knots were thee best ever."
  • "The food is so delicious, we ate the Eggplant Parmigiana and I have to say it was amazing!!!!"
  • "Everything they have is consistently delicious."

Cons:

  • "Food arrives cold everytime."
  • "We ordered a pizza and for delivery and the dough was a literally raw, completely uncooked."
  • "Ordered through Uber Eats... The pizza was also cold."
  • "The pizza was ok tasted a little rubbery."
  • "The pizza however was very disappointing. Cheese was a bit skimpy, crust was very bland, and the sauce tasted like straight tomato sauce with no salt or seasoning."
  • "...the pasta with clam sauce, it has taken all my energy and concentration to avoid breaking my dental work on pieces of clamshell littered throughout the dinner entree."
  • "The primavera pasta was vile... The tomatoes were rotten!"

Service

Pros:

  • "The friendly staff did an excellent job at making us feel welcomed and comfortable."
  • "The servers are very welcoming and friendly service."
  • "The service has always been extraordinary as well."
  • "Some of the best service I've ever received!"
  • "Service was delightful. I would recommend a visit!"
  • "The service was phenomenal and extremely accommodating (Thank you Rose!!)"
  • "Waitress was attentive the food was excellent."

Cons:

  • "I rarely have 3 issues in 1 delivery, but this was the one."
  • "There was bugs in our drinks, and when the waiter came over she was acting like she knew there was a bug in their."
  • "2 hours after I ordered, and 4 phone calls I finally find out my order was sitting on the porch."
  • "The service was absolutely abysmal. Twenty minutes to get water, the meals didn't come out together."
  • "Also the older lady who served us was very rude, didn’t want to serve us clearly and snatched our menus from us."
  • "Whenever I contacted the restaurant, they either pretended to not hear me or told me to call back in 10 minutes if the order did not arrive."
  • "Delivery people are rude and don’t even say thank you with a nice tip."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "The restaurant is clean tables are clean it’s in a nice area."
  • "Clean and sociable environment."
  • "Went with my family one day and it was overall nice and peaceful."
  • "The dining area is more upscale than a typical pizza place."
  • "The atmosphere was charming as well, giving off Italian and NJ ambiance which is obvious to outsiders such as myself."
  • "Great for dinner with friends or out with your family."
  • "This restaurant made me feel HAPPY~~ reasonably priced dishes great pizza very friendly staff home made taste yummy food not too salty not too greasy and generous portions."

Cons:

  • "It's not as much of a dining venue for big dates, but it is more for family place so there will be families and kids there."
  • "The toilets were absolutely discussing."
  • "I was treated as if I wasn't welcomed in this restaurant, overall, left me with an uncomfortable feeling."
  • "This place was absolutely disgusting I’ve never had Italian food in NEW JERSEY this bad."
  • "Set for a long time with no one to take the order."
  • "For starters water was never brought out."
  • "How this place has any good reviews is baffling. Absolutely appalled at what I've seen."

Value

Pros:

  • "The best sign for great food at a descent price is that his place is always busy...lunch or dinner."
  • "Very reasonably priced."
  • "Prices so very moderate for the quality and huge portions served."
  • "Considering inflation, we felt their prices were great for the quality of food and for the customer service!"
  • "The food portions are more than generous and the price was extremely fair."
  • "Best Italian in the area for your buck."
  • "Excellent pizza with thin, crispy crust; not burned. Great, fresh toppings; very reasonably priced."

Cons:

  • "Horrible restaurant don’t waste your money here, they are expensive for what no clue!"
  • "The bill for 20 people was $1K for cafeteria level food."
  • "They are a little on the pricey side."
  • "The fact that they are charging SIX dollars for one slice of pizza is truly insulting."
  • "That’s unacceptable and a rip off."
  • "Pepperoni flop no bite no taste."
  • "Ordered margarita pizza its dry and has a nasty taste to sauce."

Management

Pros:

  • "The manager Steve and our server Rose truly went above and beyond to make sure my grandpa had the dinner celebrating his life that he deserved."
  • "Manager was very friendly, attentive, and welcoming."
  • "They were extremely accommodating. Steve was beyond helpful."
  • "The waitress was nice. The owner Mahmud was so accommodating."
  • "Amir was a pleasure to deal with and was very accommodating to our needs."
  • "They did a great job making it right when there was an item missing from my delivery."
  • "Lovely staff (Rose) she can manage anyone (kids or adults), any number of customers, easily and make you feel at home!"

Cons:

  • "I am giving one star due to manager who worked on 12/16/22 at 6pm... THEN ACCUSED ME OF PUTTING BANDAID MYSELF AND WOULDNT GIVE ME HIS NAME!!!"
  • "I later found out that restaurant manager had no idea about donation stuff which made me feel suspicious."
  • "Owner is a greedy snake who lacks customer service skills."
  • "Never never order from here. Very rude place."
  • "I just went back today and the owner was there, and I will never go back to this place again, he was so disrespectful to me."
  • "Skip it! Really tasteless food and management."
  • "The only reason this restaurant gets two stars is because the quality of the food is somewhat good. The staff, especially the All Egyptian management, are untrustworthy, rude, scandalous, disrespectful, and not a touch friendly."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.