"The food was very tasty, but on the rich side so be prepared to get very full!"
"The food was simply exquisite, with each dish showcasing the culinary mastery of the chefs."
"Everything we ordered was delicious, and the French toast was especially amazing."
"The food was fantastic – every bite was a delight."
Cons:
"The food falls way short of what we should expect at the venerable Hotel Chelsea."
"The food was really mediocre. The chef seemed to only be acquainted with salt and mustard as condiments."
"The viral raviolis: a disappointment! Maybe because it hyped up but I found the texture to be soft and the flavor to be bland with hints of something tomato."
"Food is WAY overpriced for the portions that you get and the tastes were not unique."
"Some of the food here is overly seasoned – dishes are too salty and acidic, lacking depth overall."
"The food to be subpar."
"Good for drinks! Nice ambience. Really mediocre food, the price doesn’t justify the food."
Service
Pros:
"Service was impeccable - we felt very cared for throughout our dinner."
"The service is friendly and attentive - not pretentious like other trendy restaurants in NYC."
"The service was amazing."
"The staff was very attentive and constantly clearing plates for us to enjoy the next course."
"Our server (I think her name was Hannah) was really great- the service was attentive but not overbearing."
"The service was impeccable, with attentive staff ensuring that every need was met promptly and courteously."
"Our waitress was very hospitable and kind."
Cons:
"Service is bland and not overly accommodating."
"Service was slow, but I think that’s more to understaffing than the waitstaff fault."
"Decent service, nothing outstanding though."
"We were not checked on after that for another 10 minutes."
"Service was slow and ok."
"The service was quick, to the point and a bit cold/unfriendly."
"Rude, disrespectful, not well mannered staff who refuse to service the guests."
Ambiance
Pros:
"The atmosphere is lovely- French bistro style."
"The atmosphere and decor of Cafe Chelsea is amazing."
"Cozy and very pleasant atmosphere, bold colors and tiling, rich wood and brass accents."
"The ambiance exudes elegance and sophistication, setting the perfect tone for a memorable dining experience."
"Café, Chelsea is a really great spot to go for a date night or with a group of friends. The ambience is truly unmatched."
"The restaurant has such a cozy, French vibe."
"Parisian vibes, I feel like I was in Europe!!!!"
Cons:
"The atmosphere was contrived and very loud."
"Whoever designed it didn't take into account acoustics... very uncomfortable to sit there, and have a conversation."
"Very much a place where you go not for the food but for the aesthetics."
"It was a tad bit noisy though given how popular this place has become."
"The inside is very dark at night so you can feel beautiful bc no one can see your flaws or your body 😂."
"A little bite loud, my husband did not like the cut of the steak fries."
"If you are going during rush hour, be ready for tight seating."
Value
Pros:
"Food delicious and fair priced, we had the goat cheese croquettes, the tuna crudo, the beet salad, the raviolis was my absolutely favorite!!"
"The food was amazing!!! Everything was really delicious, but my favorites: Ravioles, chicken, the tartare, the lemon pasta and the ice cream."
"Definitely the place to be in Manhattan, from the moment we arrived Annika took care of us even when the place was very busy and no tables were available."
Cons:
"Maybe some of the best fries I’ve ever had as well however albeit too expensive."
"The service and atmosphere is great but food is very basic and overpriced for what it has."
"Fantastic food but overall very pricy for super small portions, especially drinks."
"The menu options here for vegetarians and vegans is extremely limited."
"The salad was quite good, but the three pieces of tuna do not warrant a supplement of $9."
"Good for drinks! Nice ambience. Really mediocre food, the price doesn’t justify the food."
"Everything was delicious once again, the Goat Cheese Croquettes, Meyer Lemon Pasta, Maitake Mushrooms, Loup De Mer, as well as the Omelette with Frites."