"It is a great place to unwind, enjoy the view of the Hudson River and enjoy great food."
"Liberty Bistro may be one of the prettiest spots in Manhattan."
"Outdoor space near the boat marina is amazing and quite the oasis from congested Manhattan."
"The place was well kept, the ambience and view was great for a warm Saturday afternoon."
"Excellent ambiance and fabulous views!!!"
"One of the most picturesque location and stunning view of the sails on the Hudson River."
"Beautiful view of the sunset and the Hudson River."
Cons:
"Nice views, decor, music too loud."
"The only French thing about this restaurant is the service."
"The soundtrack never shifted from disco."
"When the host tried to sit my party of three, behind a big pole, blocking us from the beautiful view."
"The only negative part was that we ordered drinks from the happy hour menu and were only informed after the check that happy hour prices did not apply to outdoors seating."
"The atmosphere is perhaps the reason to eat here since it’s one of the few places I’ve seen where their outdoor seating is more popular than their indoor dining."
"The place decor and ambiance was so appealing! It turned out to be more of a Waterfront Overpriced Tourist Trap."
Service
Pros:
"Mimi - our server was delightful."
"The waitstaff was great very attentive and professional."
"The service was outstanding!"
"Impeccable service, our waiter was super attentive despite our 2 kids which disrupted our brunch experience."
"The wait staff is amazing, attentive, with above and beyond customer service."
"The service was excellent and our guests really loved the food and drinks!"
"Great staff and atmosphere! Alexis took care of us with an energetic and professional service."
Cons:
"Bad Mangament, pretentious even for a native NYer. Manager on duty was rude and unapproachable."
"I really love this place but the service is mediocre."
"Poor service; bad food equal find another place to dine."
"Our waiter barely acknowledged our presence."
"Basically there was no server at our table."
"The service was so so."
"Service was horrible every time we were there."
Food Quality
Pros:
"The Lobster roll was a very nice size an full of delicious lobster."
"Our main courses were excellent, the desserts were divine."
"Food was tasty. Branzinno was perfectly made."
"I started with the TUNA TARTARE 5 starts!!! Best I’ve had on the east coast!"
"The oysters are always fresh."
"The lobster roll dish was just perfect, with the delicious side salad."
"Ordered fish of the day and it is tender and juice."
Cons:
"Chicken was mediocre with little taste."
"While the food is decent but not at all fantastic."
"The food was not particularly great."
"The steak and the salmon were missing flavor."
"All dishes quality ingredients but flavors were off which didn't impress the palate."
"The steak tartare had so much vinegar it was nauseating."
"The food was just OK - the pasta was cold and the steak tartare was meh."
Value
Pros:
"Price is very good is complete acceptable is not very expensive at all, and worthy for the stay."
"Is a bit pricey but is definitely worth the price."
"All dishes are in mid-high price range - appropriate for portions, ambiance and the view."
"A little pricey but I can tell that it's worthy!!!"
Cons:
"The service was okay, and so was the food. Nothing worth the price but then again it’s NYC."
"Prices are rather high :)"
"What used to be a hidden gem is now an institution only a corporate-sponsored happy hour could afford to splurge on."
"Had brunch on Saturday at 2 pm, menu is absurdly overpriced."