Bodrum Mediterranean Restaurant Reviews Summary

Category: Mediterranean restaurant New York

Address: 584 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA

Phone: +12127992806

Rating: 4.4
based on 150 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "The staff is amazing. Friendly and attentive."
  • "Good service, relaxed dining, very tasty food."
  • "The servers and host were really friendly and nice and the atmosphere was comfortable and nice as well."
  • "Service was great and the food was one of the best meals any of us have had in a while."
  • "Delicious food and great friendly service."
  • "Staff constantly paying attention. great service, great food."
  • "The service was also extremely kind and friendly."

Cons:

  • "Waiters running here and there. Short of staff."
  • "Service awful."
  • "And waiters are in the end greedy for the tips they will ask you questions if you even forgot to add any tip in the bill."
  • "I asked why we were being ignored and she replied 'did you go inside and ask to be properly seated by the hostess?'"
  • "The hostess removed us from our seats and said she could not seat us."
  • "The hostess was unbelievably rude to us during lunch on 10/24/2021."
  • "Definitely not the hospitality one expects at these prices."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The mango margarita is sinfully delicious."
  • "The kebab was yummy. The tangine wasn't very large."
  • "The red sauce on the Adana dish was wonderful."
  • "The food here is great. Mezze sampler platter is a good way to try many things."
  • "The manti (large) were delicious and well portioned as an entree."
  • "The white pizza had so many kinds of cheese, it was the best I’ve had."
  • "The food was well prepared and delicious."

Cons:

  • "We ordered the lamb shank, however it didn’t have as much meat as compared to other restaurants."
  • "Menemen with sucuk was also very salty and came without any bread."
  • "The lamb tangine was ok, but was not that filling and the dumplings in our appetizer were a lot smaller than they traditionally are."
  • "The food here wasn't the best."
  • "Sigara borek was very salty and greasy."
  • "The food was ok. A bit cold."
  • "The food was extremely overpriced for what you get."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "The vibe is great whether you sit inside or outside (summer/spring)"
  • "This neighborhood gem serves fantastic brick oven pizza, addictive bread served warm from the same oven, and fantastic Turkish classics."
  • "Bodrum has done a good job with its outdoor seating and the casual Mediterranean menu lends itself to dining outside."
  • "Definitely recommend for a tasty meal in a nice atmosphere!"
  • "The atmosphere was comfortable and nice as well."
  • "It has a very welcoming appeal."
  • "The atmosphere has a nice rustic feel, with comfortable seats and good lighting."

Cons:

  • "Despite there being quite a few empty tables inside, we were turned away from indoor dining because the only empty tables were 4-seaters."
  • "The place is a bit small and tight."
  • "The announce was perfect for us older folks (over 60)."
  • "The biggest surprise is that Boldrum’s pizzas are authentically prepared... costing almost twice the price."
  • "Very quite and nice place clean and food taste great."
  • "The restaurant is rustic but welcoming and authentic."
  • "Really everything. The food and the atmosphere are all authentic."

Value

Pros:

  • "Price that match the quality of the food."
  • "Good service, price that match the quality of the food."
  • "The food is good and reasonably priced."
  • "Fair prices for nice meal out."
  • "The prices are very reasonable."
  • "Good food at reasonable prices."
  • "Good food at reasonable prices with fast and friendly service; Turkish coffee a plus."

Cons:

  • "Ordered takeout, way overpriced."
  • "When I wanted to pay for the food we were charged extra because we were a 'large party' only because we came with 6 persons."
  • "The food is a little overpriced - probably because it is the best Mediterranean spot in a 10 block radius."
  • "Ordered food through Grubhub. Not sure if 5 pieces of dry lamb and extremely coarse grain flavorless saffron-less non-basmati rice is worth 22$."
  • "Ordered takeout, way overpriced."
  • "Went there to try their popular lamb tagine on Saturday afternoon. Disappointment."
  • "The biggest surprise is that Boldrum’s pizzas are authentically prepared... costing almost twice the price."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.