Address: 840 Rte 9W, Fort Montgomery, NY 10922, USA
Phone: +18459778003
Rating: 4.3
based on 136 reviews.
Food Quality
Pros:
"Their food was AMAZING!!!"
"Went here last year and it was the best pizza ever!"
"We ordered a Margarita, incredible! Then we ask for linguini with clams, I asked for parmigiana egg plants with linguini, everything was great!"
"Pizza quality was very good! Specially we liked the base. It was thin, crispy and seemed quite fresh!"
"The ‘sexy pizza’ is true to its name! Heavenly crust with just the right amount of sauce, cheese and basil."
"Ingredients are incredible and fresh. The sauce has a rich taste, and the crust is insanely good!"
"The penne a la vodka pizza is to die for, the flavor is absolutely incredible and very filling especially after a hike at bear mountain."
Cons:
"The lasagna was horrible! They give you the lasagna dress down with lots of sauce and cheese, in the inside of lasagna was cold and the taste OMH old ground beef with no taste whatsoever!"
"Pizza falls apart impossible to eat without a fork and knife and the sauce was way too sweet."
"Unfortunately the BBQ chicken tasted like Buffalo chicken, the chicken tenders was extremely dry and the fries had no taste and the pizza slice was like what was few days old."
"Supreme pizza (Peppers, onions, black olives, mushrooms, sausage & pepperoni) order came with only pepperoni, sausage and broccoli. Pizza was horrible."
"The pizza slices was dry and stiff, cheese wasn’t cheesy and I barely finished the one slice."
"Worst tasting pasta ever! Its uneatable!"
"Pizza overpriced and it was like cardboard the cheese was falling off from the amount of grease that was in the pizza."
Service
Pros:
"The music being played makes you feel like you are on a mini vacation to Italy!"
"The lady who’s name is Providence gave us a big smile and said of course."
"They were friendly and welcoming!"
"They were very attentive and we felt appreciated and would gladly return again....definitely recommend!"
"Service was excellent and the pizza was delicious."
"The staff / owners were so attentive to customer needs and exceed expectations on such a busy day! Love you guys! Great Team. Great Food. Great Experience!"
"Staff was extremely friendly and personable."
Cons:
"Service was absolute trash! We walked in, the server looked annoyed to have another table and told us to sit at any open spot."
"But since they reopened we have ordered twice, and both times the pizza was incorrect."
"They don't answer their phones so to order for pickup you have to go through slice."
"Service wasn't bad.. but wasn't good either. Waiter forgot an item i ordered, and I had to go out of my way to remind them."
"terrible service There is only one waitress who serves more than 10 tables at the same time."
"And the man who gave me my food was rude and acted like I impeaded his whole day by picking up my food."
"Some of the worst customer service I've experienced... my delivery order was over 20 minutes late, worker on phone hung up twice before I was finished speaking."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"Great place to stop and relax before going back to the City."
"It has a cozy outdoor area where you can seat and eat."
"This place is so warm and welcoming - a perfect mixture of an old school charm (Italian classics on the radio) with the creme de la creme in Italian cuisine."
"The pizza was da bomb! Fresh and delicious served with a small-town genuine smile."
"The atmosphere was great and a nice vibe in the area will surely keep you comfy with scenery to enjoy your food."
"Cozy place with genuinely nice staff!"
"What a great, friendly environment. The waitress Jennifer, was delightful, her helper (first day on the job!) was incredibly attentive, the owner was welcoming and gracious."
Cons:
"Terrible place! I almost got food poisoning from eating their food. Beware... they play favoritism.. because we were seated outside in the rain while there were seats indoor."
"the interior of the restaurant could use a major upgrade. wood around windows rotted and nasty, tables are all wobbly etc."
"Weird place. Walked in and there was a cart of suits and cologne, like a mini yard sale in the entryway."
"The building is beautiful, but only a small part is open and it is extremely hot during the summer."
"Small selection of Pizza... Dining in is roughing it. You have to eat in a noisy and cold porch."
"the dinning area is a mess, very hot with no shades to protect the costumers from the sunlight..."
"Not a good place to work, at all."
Value
Pros:
"They also serve private label soda. The prices seem reasonable on the menu."
"Family owned business. Pizza was delicious! Highly recommend if you want a quick, delicious bite to eat and are visiting the Bear Mountain area."
"Our favorite pizza place here, hands down! We've tried probably every type of pizza, garlic knots, stuffed rice balls, calzone, gelato... Not a single bad experience."
"The service is great and the prices more than fair."
"Excellent pizza for a fair price."
"Real value for money.. food is delicious.. had pizza...really nice."
"The people making the pizza are from Calabria, they make the best pizza super light with fresh ingredients no preservatives."
Cons:
"It cost 18.22 for a full sausage pizza. But they had the audacity to charge me the same price for 4 slices and when I questioned him about it he tried to defend it."
"I usually don’t rate places, but this really had me disturbed. I ordered their jumbo wings and although they aren’t that bad, $17.00 for 8 wings is outrageous."
"We ordered a pie, 2 sandwiches (the Italian was disappointingly scrawny) and 5 sodas. Somehow that came to $65 plus tip."
"Well I have it one star because there’s no zero way over priced over 3 dollars for one slice going rate is 250 a slice pizza isn’t even that good will not be going there again pizza in the Bronx is cheaper and way better."
"Over $15, I got the 'sexy slice' (margarita) and 2 meat lovers slice... both paper thin, and hardly anything on the not so sexy slice."
"Pizza tasted okay, but are way overpriced."
"Update - The pizza is still good but holy cow is it expensive!!"
Management
Pros:
"Bear Mountain Pizza has fed us with almost 50 pies two years in a row at Bear Mountain State Park."
"With quick friendly customer service and delicious food Bear Mountain Pizza impresses with every aspect of culinary hospitality."
"It's amazing what the chef can do out of a food truck while the main restaurant is under renovation!"
"Best grandma pie you will find outside of the city. If you are in the area this is the best place to eat."
"The large pizzas are huge and feed plenty."
"Excellent Pizza! They have a lot of menu items to choose from but their pizza is delicious."