Marley's Gotham Grill Reviews Summary

Category: Restaurant

Address: 169 Main St, Hackettstown, NJ 07840, USA

Phone: +19088522446

Rating: 4.4
based on 265 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Pricing is about average, but the higher quality of food makes it an amazing value."
  • "If you enjoy wings it is a must go."
  • "The coconut curry wings are amazing."
  • "The wings themselves were well made with a nice crisp crunch and moist meat."
  • "The Burgers are great."
  • "Every flavor we tried was fantastic."
  • "The wings were great and huge(lots of meat)."

Cons:

  • "The sandwich was a tad under my expectations as the meat was just a little on the light side."
  • "The wings were just ok. They were swimming in some sort of spicy Velveeta like cheese product."
  • "It was terribly expensive for bland food."
  • "Found a hair in my girlfriends wings, food came out cold."
  • "We wanted to like this place. I rarely leave bad reviews, but honestly these were the worst wings I've ever had."
  • "Wings are disgustingly over breaded and tossed in your choice of over 300 nonsensical, bizarre sauces."
  • "The wings were dry and the teriyaki sauce was straight up salt."

Variety

Pros:

  • "They have 250 different flavors of wings!!"
  • "This place has the best boneless wings, and a crazy selection of flavors."
  • "They have one of the most extensive wing menus I've ever seen."
  • "They had over 300 flavors of wings available for us to try."
  • "They have such delicious hot wings and OVER 300 flavors!"
  • "I got 24 wings with 4 different flavors (of their TOTAL 350 FLAVORS), and they were all absolutely incredible."
  • "Every type of sauce you can imagine for wings."

Cons:

  • "Many flavors, but wings were mediocre at best in comparison to real Buffalo wings."
  • "Their wings are from Restaurant Depot, are breaded and fried and despite '150 varieties' (or however many there are), it's all the same stuff with different sauces."
  • "Wings came extremely greasy and extra salty."
  • "LOVE their wings but I have never ever had an order that was right. If you order delivery or take out, they don't care, they won't fix it."
  • "The wings had way too much breading, way too much goopy sauce, and we're just barely cooked through."
  • "The wings are super breaded, way to much...."
  • "The wings were something worse than grocery store wings. 300+ flavors??? That’s just plain silly."

Service

Pros:

  • "Also, our waiter was patient and cool, especially when you had to think of how he dealt with 4 ladies who were indecisive."
  • "Our server Greg went above and beyond and provided us with stellar service."
  • "Service was great."
  • "Best service I’ve ever gotten here."
  • "The service has been courteous and prompt when I visited!"
  • "Service was friendly, prompt, and attentive."
  • "Our server was extremely friendly and personable ask for her when you arrive her name is Amanda!"

Cons:

  • "The waitress was good to us but she really didn’t know the food or drinks when ask what she thought of certain things."
  • "Getting service is really hard."
  • "Our server was boarderline rude."
  • "Then I asked One of the girls…where’s our appetizer and she snapped we’re working on it."
  • "Bartender wearing cowboys jersey was extremely rude and non professional."
  • "We had a terrible waitress (Keara O). She forgot to serve the white sangria that I ordered."
  • "Service was not good and we were overpriced for our wings."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The atmosphere in Marley’s is awesome!"
  • "The atmosphere was lively, and very welcoming."
  • "It’s a nice location and setup. We have always asked for outdoor seating in the front or the patio area in the back."
  • "The space is very cozy."
  • "Loved the atmosphere & easy parking."
  • "Loved the relaxed and friendly atmosphere."
  • "The atmosphere was awesome."

Cons:

  • "The men's room was messy......more than men's room generally are."
  • "Bar area too loud."
  • "There is a bar so it can get noisy."
  • "The decor and atmosphere of Marley's is tragic....picture a house that has 1970's decor."
  • "It had an extremely chaotic atmosphere."
  • "The place is wicked loud inside. Too many hard surfaces with nothing to absorb sound from rowdy tables."
  • "Inside is an unapologetic dive bar atmosphere with a huge bar."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.