Hamilton's on Main Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "Food was excellent."
• "The meal was tasty."
• "For desserts we got the Lemon vanilla cheesecake and the Tres leches both very good."
• "The sea bass was very good."
• "The food was exquisite as well."
• "The food was outstanding."
• "Every dish I tried was bursting with flavor and expertly prepared."

Cons:

• "It was under cooked severely."
• "The meals were cold and/or over cooked."
• "The fillet was over cooked and just had no flavor."
• "Food was OK but not nearly as good as it should have been for the price point."
• "The Mediterranean platter was flavorless."
• "Food was salty. Blackened scallops with risotto were overheated and mushy."
• "All dishes were oversalted and overspiced."

Service

Pros:

• "The service has been fantastic both times we've been here."
• "The bartenders were very attentive and friendly."
• "Service was timely."
• "Our server Hussain was excellent. Pleasant but not hovering."
• "Mike our waiter was so attentive and accommodating."
• "Our wonderful server Jordan knocked it out of the park with her customer care."
• "The staff were very friendly, knowledgeable and had wonderful attitudes."

Cons:

• "The waiter had no idea what any good pairings for food and drinks were."
• "The waiter we had was flat out awful and only came to our table 3 times the entire night never refilling our drinks once."
• "She never came back to fill our waters or ask us if we at least wanted to order appetizers."
• "The owner was unresponsive throughout the entire process."
• "The server was horrible."
• "Service was also subpar, as we had to keep pouring water ourselves."
• "Waitress came and took our drink order and poured water, that was the last time we saw her for 35 min."

Ambiance

Pros:

• "From the food, to the drinks our server recommended, to the beautiful decor!"
• "It's beautiful inside the restaurant and meant for a spoiling occasion or family gathering."
• "Each room is styled differently, each with such character, elegance and attention to detail, creating the most lovely ambiance."
• "The atmosphere was perfect."
• "Great atmosphere!"
• "The place IS impeccably decorated with every nook and cranny being filled with layers of decor."
• "The decor of Hamilton's on Main is nothing short of stunning."

Cons:

• "It's also seriously noisy inside."
• "There was also a Barbie pop-up during the time of our event and those decorations were not taken down and did not fit the theme of our event."
• "It's so cozy and decorations are really nice."
• "Atmosphere is the only average thing I'd say could use improvement. A bit bland in the main dining area."
• "The overall atmosphere of the restaurant is classy but not 'stuffy'."
• "The noise level was unbearable."
• "The vibe was so good - definitely didn't feel like your typical restaurant."