Schilling Restaurant & Bar Reviews Summary

Category: Austrian restaurant New York

Address: 109 Washington St, New York, NY 10006, USA

Phone: +12124061200

Rating: 4.4
based on 114 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The crispy cauliflower was also perfectly cooked."
  • "The food was absolutely amazing, and this reel is just part one of what we tried."
  • "Everything was fantastisch. The schnitzel (I got the chicken) was fried to perfection."
  • "Great, authentic Austrian food. Amazing desserts!"
  • "The food is SO tasty!"
  • "All food was tasty, high-quality dishes, and down to the fresh herbs and salad, sides, and even homemade ketchup and aioli."
  • "The food was seasoned perfectly, not salty or greasy."

Cons:

  • "The trout rilettes were so salty that we could not finish. The schnitzel was not crispy enough."
  • "The Schnitzel is just ok, certainly not worth the $ 32 price tag for pork/chicken."
  • "Broccoli appetizer was overcooked, did not appear roasted as stated on menu."
  • "While tasty, the food wasn't as authentic-ly delicious as expected, especially the potato salad."
  • "The food could use a bit more flavor - the schnitzel had a wonderful seasoning on its breading but needed more of it."
  • "Everything was tasteless. No flavor."
  • "The main highlight of schnitzel was a disappointment. Flat breaded and fried meats have a lot of flavoring potential due to high surface area to volume but both the pork and chicken schnitzel we had didn't have much flavor."

Service

Pros:

  • "Service was amazing and friendly, and server was very knowledgeable."
  • "Staff warm and friendly."
  • "Our hostess (was also working the bar) was extremely nice and was very helpful with the menu."
  • "Service was excellent, concerned, helpful and efficient."
  • "The service staff was wonderful and even the chef was clearing out tables."
  • "Very attentive service and fantastic hand-crafted cocktails."
  • "The staff are incredibly attentive and go above and beyond to serve their clientele."

Cons:

  • "So we waited a long time for our food and had very spotty service."
  • "The service was honestly mediocre."
  • "We waited 30 minutes for a beer and a glass of wine, with additional delays throughout."
  • "Unfortunately the service didn't seem to have knowledge of the wine they are serving or the dishes."
  • "I had a pretty negative experience with service from one of the staff during one of my visits."
  • "The staff was friendly but very slow."
  • "Wish my waitress spoke/understood English better!!"

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The ambiance is on the romantic-industrial side, and it is quite intimate."
  • "A real find in the financial district. A place with real NY atmosphere."
  • "So comfy and cozy! Loved the communal dining atmosphere."
  • "Inside was cozy, warm, and inviting."
  • "Overall outstanding service and really nice atmosphere."
  • "You feel like you are in an old country farmhouse."
  • "Beautifully designed restaurant with good music and delicious, creative, artfully presented food."

Cons:

  • "It's VERY loud, so not great for business meetings or intimate conversation."
  • "The restaurant was really cold."
  • "The ambiance is nice but the tight quarters make it hard for the servers to provide fast service."
  • "We also had issues with the soup that made it seem it might not be the freshest."
  • "The Schnitzel is just so flatz tasteless...."
  • "The restaurant is a very small space which makes it that much more impressive what they’ve done with it."
  • "The entrance is divided into two ways, One is for Normal people and other is for unfit people which are on the wheelchairs."

Portion Size

Pros:

  • "The portions are very generous too."
  • "Bang for your buck it’s the best in the city."
  • "The portion sizes were insane and we saw practically everyone taking the leftovers home in boxes."
  • "The schnitzel portion was smaller than pretty much every German restaurant I've ever been to, but it was still a very filling meal."
  • "The portions were generous, making it not just a feast for our taste buds but also a treat for our wallets."
  • "For just $45, we indulged in a dinner that was nothing short of splendid."
  • "We loved the Spaetzle and Rib Eye, both flavorful and cooked to perfection."

Cons:

  • "The food portions are so small."
  • "The serving sizes were cut down to the point where it is embarrassing."
  • "The food was good but it didnt have much options when it comes to eating."
  • "3 thick asparagus shoots, 3 slices of cold cut ham, one or two chunks of purple potato = $38. I was in shock with how measly the portions were."
  • "The food was good but portions were on the small side."
  • "A few vegan items were not available from the regular menu which was disappointing on a Friday."
  • "Some things were blatantly over-priced, such as the $4 cokes (no refills)."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.