MEXiCUE Reviews Summary

Category: Mexican restaurant New York

Address: 1440 Broadway, New York, NY 10018, USA

Phone: +13322498600

Rating: 4.3
based on 241 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The sweetness from these nachos along with the freshness of all ingredients was superb."
  • "The food is soooo amazing like really really good."
  • "The Mexican street corn, grilled cornbread, jamburrito, chicken, shrimp and brisket tacos are amazing."
  • "The food was brilliant especially the Brisket!"
  • "Food was delicious. Had the guacamole and chips, pulled pork rice bowl, lobster tacos and avocado and chicken slider - all dishes were fresh and tasty."
  • "It was hands down THE BEST vegetarian dish I’ve ever had."
  • "The food and drinks had all the flavor you’d hope for."

Cons:

  • "It was the worst experience I had at a restaurant maybe it's my luck but I don't know."
  • "Horrible experience."
  • "Food isn't bad, but the portions are very very small."
  • "Not a single item was tasty. Considering the food is overpriced, you'd expect it to be good. Wrong."
  • "The food was eh, the service was pretty bad."
  • "The food is average."
  • "Food was different. Some of it was too spicy (brisket specifically) but I loved the chicken burrito."

Service

Pros:

  • "Servers were friendly and helpful."
  • "They were beyond attentive and helpful and their customer service is always on point."
  • "Our server was helpful with recommendations and the service was fast and quality."
  • "Staff was really friendly & attentive."
  • "Staff is friendly and helpful."
  • "Our bartender was friendly and attentive."
  • "The staff were attentive and friendly and the food was extremely tasty and beautifully presented."

Cons:

  • "Unfortunately, let down by the service. Waiter forgot about us a few times."
  • "Horrible. I called to place a large order for my monthly company's lunch... I will DEFINITELY be taking my business elsewhere."
  • "Just terrible service, didn’t feel welcome."
  • "Good and friendly service overall, but I think the servers are stretched a little thin."
  • "Buttt the service sucks so if you don’t like being in awkward situations where you have to ask the waitress to wait on you, maybe get takeout."
  • "The service was lacking. We hardly saw our waitress."
  • "Rude server, I had ordered a salad and the ingredients in a salad looked dead and super cold."

Ambience

Pros:

  • "Fun atmosphere and great food."
  • "The restaurant is so quaint & has some really great vibes."
  • "The atmosphere is very cosy and alive with excited chatter."
  • "The location we went to had great decor and ambience as well as friendly service."
  • "Atmosphere here is that of a relaxed nature and a good place to come to unwind."
  • "Very cozy place. Might ask for their playlist too!"
  • "Delightful green and wood interior."

Cons:

  • "Small, cozy, tasty, fresh, lively Mexican food served with friendly smiles but seating was upsetting."
  • "Dining room smoky with cooking odors."
  • "This place is entirely too small."
  • "The specific location has too much of a coffee shop vibe."
  • "The space is small though the ambience is cozy and inviting."
  • "The space is WAY too packed. It was hard to get out and navigate through the tables."
  • "The place is pretty small and tables are very close to each other."

Value

Pros:

  • "Price (30 USD per person for a lot of food and a drink) is okay for this great food."
  • "Everything was fantastic and reasonably priced for the quality of food."
  • "And the prices, for being in Midtown, were really good."
  • "Prices are real good."
  • "Excellent value for money and I would definitely recommend."
  • "Very good, reasonably priced food (for NYC) and fun cocktails!"
  • "Great food, great drinks, great staff!"

Cons:

  • "Not worth it for the price, and can always go to Applebee's for cheap microwaved food and still get the same atmosphere and services."
  • "Extremely cheap with their portions & ingredients."
  • "At $8 a taco, it's tad expensive."
  • "City prices... came out to $95 which was a bit steep I thought."
  • "Very less quantity for a 14$ to go salad should pack more nutrition!!"
  • "Is crazy how they over charge people."
  • "This is sort of hyped up restaurant. It is too expensive for both the drinks as well as the food."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.