Brother's Pizzeria Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "Always a great experience! Food is consistently delicious and Giorgio and family always warm and welcoming!"
• "Their pizza is like dying and going to Heaven!."
• "The pizza and other food items were great!"
• "You can't find a chicken roll like theirs anywhere else! Their sauce is among the best I've had."
• "The pizza is hot and fresh and very tasty."
• "Best pie ever. Plain cheese. Takes a big boy to house it to the face and the sauce, cheese and crust are flawless."
• "The pizza was memorable!!"

Cons:

• "I will never go back again. I asked if a fresh pie was coming out of the oven the guy says 'no'."
• "The pizza has become over priced, and there was no sauce on this pie we ate."
• "I usually love their pizza. I like more than deninos but the last time i was there i feel like the pizza didn’t taste the same."
• "I ordered two grandma squares and nothing about them was memorable."
• "The pizza sauce is definitely not the same. It used to be sweeter, which is better for pizza."
• "The pizza tasted like they forgot seasonings."
• "The cheese tasted off sauce was terrible."

Service

Pros:

• "And they care of there customers if a mistake is done."
• "The service is great and the pizza is just like from Italy."
• "Have gotten great service when I've been there."
• "The service is still the same..... friendly and fast."
• "Service was friendly and quick for a walk-in."
• "The staff are helpful. Service is fast and friendly."
• "The staff was very friendly and willing to help me with whatever I needed."

Cons:

• "I stopped in there to buy 2 slices and I was standing there at the counter and no one asked may they help me."
• "Unsanitary!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Someone scratched there private touched food."
• "This place is a scam!! What Pizzeria in 2023 only uses cash."
• "Their customer service is non-existent."
• "Pathetic truly pathetic no one answers the phone even during their hours."
• "Asked to speak to the manager and they hung up on us."
• "Really rude customer service."

Price

Pros:

• "The size of the slice was not bad either and $3.00 is about average, esp in NY."
• "Reasonable prices & they kept it going despite the pandemic era we are in."
• "It is decently priced the pie was 18 dollars and I practically threw my money at them."
• "Price of $7 was fair."

Cons:

• "The pizza has become over priced."
• "Spent 37 dollars for a large square pie and two waters for stale pizza."
• "Good food but bit overpriced for NY."
• "Decent pizza but immensely overpriced, especially when it comes to their Sicilian pie."
• "Too expensive for a pie long time customer that's why we need a Pizza Hut on the island."
• "Very disappointing. And expensive."
• "Too expensive for a pie."

Cleanliness

Pros:

• "The dining room is always clean."

Cons:

• "Tables and chairs weren’t clean I had to grab a napkin and clean my own table and floors were also dirty."
• "Unsanitary!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Someone scratched there private touched food."
• "Great pizza ... but unsanitary the guy took money then touched my plate then the pizza with still the dirty hand..... why are they not wearing gloves."
• "THERES ALWAYS NEW WORKERS AND NOT EVERYONE STAND ON SANITARY PRECAUTIONS AND NEVER PARKING."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "This place is a touch of Italy nestled away! It has a real vibe from the grab and go counter to the well lit dining area."
• "An amazing Pizzeria atmosphere, not romantic, but a traditional busy energetic Pizzeria atmosphere!"
• "Very spacious dining area."

Cons:

• "The noise in the dining caused tremendous stress. Screaming kids running around while patents just sat and Ste and ignored them."
• "The atmosphere wasn't as welcoming (family friendly) as it once was."