Forgione Reviews Summary

Category: American restaurant New York

Address: 30 Hudson St, New York, NY 10013, USA

Phone: +12129419401

Rating: 4.6
based on 158 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "The service is top notch! From beginning to end!"
  • "And the service is excellent - friendly, intimate, professional and helpful."
  • "Service was also best in class. Felt very welcome, generally homey environment."
  • "Service was top notch and consistent."
  • "Our waitress was knowledgeable, attentive and lovely!"
  • "Service was terrific and the wine list extensive."
  • "Warm, knowledgeable staff provides an extra layer to the experience that is not to be missed."

Cons:

  • "Also the wine service was poor. We waited way too long for bottles to open and our glasses were empty for an annoyingly long time."
  • "We complained about them being so rude and out of control and the restaurant did nothing about it."
  • "Service was good, but again not exceptional."
  • "Except for our waitress. She was short and rude with us."
  • "Service was perfunctory but efficient, as delivered by a team of sprinting Eastern European girls."
  • "Service was lacking a bit considering we were one of few tables."
  • "The service should be more attentive for a restaurant of this caliber."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The atmosphere was inviting, rustic with a nice mix of industrial touches."
  • "A dim, bustling ambiance at night makes for a non-intrusive dining environment, worthy of dates or even business dinners."
  • "The ambiance is beautiful."
  • "You will fall in love with the ambiance the minute you walk in the door."
  • "Ambience and atmosphere is awesome, is cozy and intimate, yet down home."
  • "When you enter you feel a very comforting ambiance. It is definitely a warm homie feeling."
  • "The atmosphere was beautiful....very warm and inviting."

Cons:

  • "Restaurant was a way too loud. The only way to talk was to yell, which everybody did."
  • "There is community seating in the bar which worked for us but it was noisy."
  • "This place is LOUD -- like, sports bar loud. Decor is very rustic and dark."
  • "The restaurant was dark, homey and bit loud."
  • "NOT TODDLER FRIENDLY."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Desserts are very good for a sweet tooth."
  • "This place never disappoints. The Lobster Chili is a must."
  • "The star of the menu is the Bell & Evan Roast Chicken for Two."
  • "Every single bite was impeccable."
  • "Hands down one of the best food experiences."
  • "The duck with cherry sauce was among the best duck dishes we've had."
  • "The food was absolutely delicious; I really enjoyed the chili lobster Texas toast."

Cons:

  • "EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED with this expensive place where the food was just mediocre."
  • "Pot au Veau - very disappointing dish, this specific cut was mostly fat, gummy and not tasty at all."
  • "The beer selection is terrible."
  • "My wife got the scallops, and they were a disappointment."
  • "The wagyu lardo pasta was too al dente. The halibut sauce was way too salty."
  • "The black bass was mediocre, and really don't recommend getting this."
  • "The terrine was dry, the duck disappointing in it presentation and portion size and the creme brûlée was more like a watery custard."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.