Traif Reviews Summary

Category: American restaurant New York

Address: 229 S 4th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, USA

Phone: +13478449578

Rating: 4.5
based on 224 reviews.

Atmosphere & Ambiance

Pros:

  • "They have an inside set of tables, and a small covered outside patio area which I imagine would be lovely in the summer."
  • "Loved their backyard setting, with all the lights and plants makes it feel a bit homely."
  • "Beautiful atmosphere, lively but not too loud, great lighting."
  • "Non-pretentious intimate environment, serving harmoniously paired flavors and textures, like an orchestra for the taste buds."
  • "Tastefully decorated outdoor space with lights and grapevine gives this place additional charm."
  • "The outdoor patio is very wholesome and a perfect date night spot."
  • "The ambiance was great where we sat in the back patio."

Cons:

  • "We showed up promptly to our reservation only to be shown the worst seat in the house, in the corner of a mosquito filled backyard and next to a loud speaker with awful techno music."
  • "It was so loud that it was hard to hold a conversation."
  • "The restaurant smelled of frying oil from the kitchen."
  • "So beware if your eyes and nose are sensitive."
  • "The space is cramped though once they open back up be prepared."
  • "There's a fine line between 'shabby chic' and just plan old 'shabby.' I feel this place was on the wrong side of that line -- at least in the 'garden room.'"
  • "Made us wait outside in the freezing cold after checking our vaccination cards, due to a seating delay."

Service

Pros:

  • "The wait staff was really great to seat us and let us know that they needed the table back in an hour--which ended up meaning our food was expedited and it was awesome."
  • "We had 5 staffs greeting us as we walked in."
  • "Service was great and the food came out at a good pace even though the place was busy in a Saturday night."
  • "The server and owner were very congenial."
  • "Our server was fantastic, too."
  • "Great service as well!"
  • "Service was lovely. Would highly recommend."

Cons:

  • "Service was poor, really untrained, inattentive and actually sloppy."
  • "The speed of the kitchen was uneven; we weren't yet finished with the previous course when the next one was already coming to the table."
  • "20% mandatory tip added insult to injury. never again."
  • "We got there early for our reservation which we don’t expect to be seated but we were hardly even acknowledged."
  • "Slow and inattentive service. Waiters would scream the name of the dish and just plomp it onto table and walk away."
  • "We were seated at the bar and asked 3 different staff members for water before we finally got some halfway through dinner."
  • "Service was a little slow and lackluster."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Just about everything on the menu is delicious."
  • "An incredible tasting menu, every dish was outstanding."
  • "Salt & pepper shrimp: DELICIOUS!"
  • "Food was amazing, richly flavored, beautifully presented, and adequately paced."
  • "Each dish was crafted beautifully and were just as tasty as they looked."
  • "Literally every dish was perfection."
  • "The food tasted amazing and the service was great."

Cons:

  • "Also, sitting next to the kitchen will leave a greasy smell to your clothes."
  • "The only thing I wasn’t a fan of was the strawberry ribs, maybe I was too full at that time!"
  • "The steak was tough and did not taste like a quality cut."
  • "The pork fillet mignon was a bit dry."
  • "The fried red snapper was the weakest dish, filet and batter very bland, unseasoned."
  • "A couple of plates were incredibly salty (I'm looking at you, gnocchi)."
  • "The food was sloppy, over seasoned and the purées, risotto more like creamed corn and salty, tough octopus were nearly just plain bad."

Value

Pros:

  • "You really can’t beat 11 courses for $55, especially when the courses are scallops, foie gras, duck."
  • "You get amazing value for your money."
  • "We left feeling satisfied and genuinely full—a rarity with tasting menus."
  • "For the quality of food and service, the price was so reasonable."
  • "The prices were surprisingly reasonable."
  • "For $56 a pop, Traif’s tasting menu is a steal."
  • "The $56 per person cost is worth every penny."

Cons:

  • "The food was ok but the wine was unbelievably bad and undrinkable at a price of $55 plus a bottle."
  • "20% service tax is included but don't expect to have your wine poured for you or have your plates cleared."
  • "The portions were tiny and almost comical to be split between 2 people."
  • "But we were not full at the end. We went for a slice down the block when we were finished."
  • "A bit on the expensive side but well worth it for a special occasion."
  • "They also added 20% gratuity to our bill for a table of 2, citing 'we do this when we're a full house'."
  • "Made us wait outside in the freezing cold after checking our vaccination cards, due to a seating delay."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.