Bailey's Smokehouse Reviews Summary

Category: Barbecue restaurant

Address: 136 E Erie St, Blauvelt, NY 10913, USA

Phone: +18453981454

Rating: 4.5
based on 237 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "Our waiter Edgar was very helpful and very patient with us."
  • "Great service too!"
  • "The service is friendly."
  • "Service was excellent."
  • "Our waitress Cara was phenomenal. She was waiting on several other tables but she made sure to check in on us quite frequently."
  • "Our kids loved the burger and grilled cheese and the service was amazing!"
  • "Waitress provided great service and the portion sizes are reasonable for what you pay for."

Cons:

  • "The waiter also didn’t come by more than once about 15 minutes after we got our food."
  • "Cheryl failed to tell us that the mac & cheese is considered 2 sides, and never told us."
  • "Server had no clue about the food he was bringing to the table."
  • "We wanted to tell our waitress but she was rarely present, never checked on our food."
  • "Serviss was nice but completely inattentive."
  • "The server seemed upset after we asked her to clean the table when we arrived, plus she had a bit of an attitude throughout the meal."
  • "The service was okay, but our waitress didn't seem to care and had an attitude after we left an 18% tip."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Whatever we ate was pretty good. Onion soup is very nice. U can see that they made it from scratch."
  • "Good brisket/burnt ends."
  • "Their corn souffle is out this world, there table share platters are well worth the price, the beer always taste fresh."
  • "Possibly 1 of the best Brussels and bacon I've ever had."
  • "This place is the definition of finger lickin' good!"
  • "We had the Sampler Platter as an appetizer and everything on the platter was delicious especially the Mac and Cheese Eggrolls."
  • "The pulled pork was absolutely delicious and the bourbon carrots and garlic mashed potatoes were equally good."

Cons:

  • "The brisket was dry as hell."
  • "The meatloaf is weird as it tastes like either chili or taco seasoning plus mushy."
  • "The brisket was gross. It was clear that it was old brisket reheated with some BBQ sauce on it."
  • "Wings were raw on the inside and there was no sauce on the wings and pizza was cold."
  • "The ribs were dry and bland."
  • "All the meats were extremely dry. The brisket was extremely lean."
  • "The baby back ribs were really, really dry and tasteless."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "Friendly neighborhood bar with great atmosphere."
  • "Nice place. Very friendly. Will return."
  • "Overall feel was very comfortable."
  • "Was there to watch the Dallas cowboys game.... Great food great drinks great atmosphere."
  • "Great smokehouse barbecue, excellent food with a great bar and dining area upstairs, and a dining area and bar downstairs that you can rent out for events."
  • "I love the ambience of this bar. Great place to watch the game."
  • "The atmosphere is cozy, lots of people laughing and having fun."

Cons:

  • "It was very loud and difficult to talk to each other across the table."
  • "Just beware of the noise level. Acoustics in this place are not good so voices are over loud."
  • "The whole place smells like a dirty old wooden floor. Not pleasant."
  • "The atmosphere was brought down by a couple at the next table who were on their phones the entire time, playing a trivia game with the volume on full."
  • "Dining area is dated."
  • "If you are not into loud environments this is not the place for you!"
  • "Most annoying was the men’s room... On top of not being clean and no-soap... There was no lock on the door... And no door on the bathroom stall.. no privacy what so ever."

Value

Pros:

  • "Their corn souffle is out this world, there table share platters are well worth the price, the beer always taste fresh."
  • "Pricing was reasonable."
  • "They consistently deliver on what's promised."
  • "The prices at this restaurant were reasonable."
  • "Good prices too."
  • "Got lots of great food for a great price."
  • "Great food, reasonably priced."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.