Main Course Marketplace Reviews Summary

Category: American restaurant New Paltz, New York

Address: 175 Main St, New Paltz, NY 12561, USA

Phone: +18452552600

Rating: 4.7
based on 125 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Their menu was imaginative, true to the season, varied (with something for everyone), and most importantly -- delicious."
  • "Great food with awesome vegan gluten free options."
  • "The smoked salmon with a tart aioli, smoked turkey with chipotle spread and the summer squash with mozzarella and roasted tomato jam were raved about."
  • "Healthy, delicious, artful."
  • "The food was fantastic and everyone said it was the best they had ever had at a wedding."
  • "Food id elegantly served and prepared with love."
  • "The food in this place is serious business. It's great prices for a very very curated menu."

Cons:

  • "The table we sat at was dirty and we never saw an employee come out from behind the counter to address the tables people were using."
  • "It was difficult maneuvering around people; there must be a collision and plate drop at least a few times per week."
  • "The bread was a bit chewy."
  • "Interesting restaurant style... but they were a little under seasoned and cold."
  • "The butternut squash soup was not thick and richly flavored, the mother of the bride thought it was celery soup it was so watery."
  • "Very disappointed with my lentil veggie burger yesterday. It was very dry, over-cooked and overspiced with pepper."
  • "Serving of chicken salad to take out was not fresh. Sickening."

Service

Pros:

  • "Kind and efficient staff."
  • "The service was quick."
  • "Clean and hospitable environment, reasonable prices."
  • "The staff responded brilliantly when the weather turned everything upside down."
  • "Counter service from friendly staff."
  • "The service was immaculate and our guests were all made to feel comfortable and accommodated."
  • "Everybody behind the counter is so nice and service is very quick."

Cons:

  • "When you check out they have you choose between three ridiculously high tip values."
  • "Service was horrible. Took forever to get my order ready."
  • "I was very disappointed and their professionalism was also horrible."
  • "Main Course was very difficult to work with after the event; it took them 14 days to respond to my email and a full month to set up a phone meeting."
  • "Service is almost always snotty. Seemingly stuck up and never willing to alter menu items to accommodate gluten-free requests."
  • "I immediately wanted to leave with our kids when one of the staff snapped at me in front of people for asking a question."
  • "In a word, terrible. I waited 40 minutes after placing my order - 40!!"

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The decor is charming and sunny, too."
  • "The place itself is beautiful and so peaceful with a lot of sunlight coming in."
  • "A real gem."
  • "Main Course Marketplace had a light, comfortable, laid-back atmosphere."
  • "Such a special spot... great atmosphere."
  • "The atmosphere was so cozy and inviting."
  • "Absolutely loved the whole vibe. Great salad. So fresh. Loved the open feel of eating area."

Cons:

  • "Seating can be limited/ fill up quick, especially on the weekend."
  • "There is a lot with very limited parking, and it is very crowded inside."
  • "Their dining room could benefit from better design."
  • "It can often be crowded and hard to find a seat, and the outdoor chairs are metal, a terrible idea if it's cold out."
  • "Only one restroom. There was a line to use it."
  • "It's a lot of hassle and not cheap for mediocre food."
  • "I ordered a slice of carrot cake and had paid for it and the lady sold my slice to someone else."

Value

Pros:

  • "Good prices."
  • "Food is pretty well priced too, especially considering the quality of the food."
  • "All were delicious and beautifully presented... They were also reasonably priced."
  • "Great food at very reasonable prices."
  • "Food is delicious! And not too expensive."
  • "The food was amazing and the prices were reasonable."
  • "Very reasonably price as well."

Cons:

  • "Price points are equal if not MORE than restaurants in the area that have proper wait staff service."
  • "Main Course ice/mixers are priced at $10pp, our friends who were married in August in upstate NY paid $4 for ice/mixers pp."
  • "It just really feels unfair to ask / pressure your customers into leaving a big tip when your staff doesn’t do anything to actually SERVICE their customers."
  • "For a 'farm to table' place, there are surprisingly few vegan options."
  • "1$ for bread with the soup? Penny pinch much???"
  • "Enjoy the money you scammed from me, Main Course, and spend it slowly because you just lost a customer for life."
  • "It was very difficult get quality time on the phone or in person with Main Course Staff."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.