Crompton Ale House Reviews Summary

Category: Irish restaurant New York

Address: 159 W 26th St, New York, NY 10001, USA

Phone: +12126580089

Rating: 4.3
based on 140 reviews.

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "We thoroughly enjoyed the atmosphere and food, seated at the high top tables in the bar area, our first visit."
  • "The dim lighting and quaint decor added to the ambiance."
  • "This place made us feel that we had stepped back in time."
  • "The atmosphere inside is still really great. It's a very warm, nice space, and the TV situation is great for sports."
  • "Love at first visit - great large screen TVs everywhere you look. The bar area has space to sit, eat, room and chat as well as the rest of the restaurant."
  • "The restaurant has a nice vibe that is classic pub with a steampunk edge, with cogs as a regular theme."
  • "A wide selection of beer coupled with a stylish decor give this spot an enjoyable atmosphere."

Cons:

  • "While we can attest to the restaurant and restrooms being impeccably clean, the air deodorizer used for the bathrooms wafted to our table and ruined our dining experience."
  • "The restaurant itself is very very cute, but really loud?? like abnormally loud, maybe lower the music a little bit."
  • "It was CRAZY loud in the middle of the afternoon."
  • "The inside was loud (music) with tons of TVs everywhere."

Service

Pros:

  • "Good old and new fashioned. Absolutely on point service with funny, professional and exceptional friendly staff."
  • "Great time. We spent a week in NYC at a walk distance hotel and made it our end of the day meet up place. Friendly atmosphere. Good food and better service and bartending."
  • "Shane and all his staff were great hosts, quick service and competitive prices."
  • "The service was great, very attentive waitress who accommodated dietary needs and went over and above."
  • "The staff here made us feel very welcome, we would definitely visit again."
  • "Servers were nice and polite!"
  • "Service was excellent. Nice place to grab a drink."

Cons:

  • "Called to see what the cover charge was for fight night, the woman on the phone said it will be $25 after 9pm. We got there at 8:25 and they were already charging."
  • "The servers seem to be too pushy and appear to be angry for no reason."
  • "So I ordered a Mai Tai and the bartender didn't know how to make it."
  • "Service was ok, nothing out of the ordinary."
  • "The wait was sooo long, I think we waited about 40 min for our food, there was a lot of us, but still it was very long."
  • "Worst service I’ve had in a while."
  • "Our party waited a very long time for our dinner. We had two children and the restaurant was mostly empty. No explanation just slow."

Food & Drinks

Pros:

  • "Wings were good."
  • "Food was GREAT but the drinks were just OK."
  • "The fish taco's were incredible, buffalo wings outstanding."
  • "The burger was good, the dessert (sundae with brownies) was absolutely delicious."
  • "The guacamole & chips and the french onion soup and both plates were great."
  • "The food was really good. I had fish and chips. It was delicious!"
  • "The steak frites were absolutely delicious and they have plenty of beers on tap for you to wash it down with."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.