Angelina's Restaurant Reviews Summary

Category: Italian restaurant New York

Address: 399 Ellis St, Staten Island, NY 10307, USA

Phone: +17182272900

Rating: 4.4
based on 154 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Food was fresh and Good."
  • "Food was spectacular! Never in my life I had a more delicious pasta."
  • "Love the lobster boat we ordered. Great for 4 to 6 people. Very fresh."
  • "Excellent, generous portions of appetizers."
  • "The foods always great along with the drinks."
  • "The food was delicious and well priced."
  • "The food from the appetizers to the entrees were amazing."

Cons:

  • "But $500 for 2 people was not worth it."
  • "The food is disgusting I can't believe it I pay $500 today for nothing!!!"
  • "The food was decent but definitely not worth the price."
  • "Food was very untasted and very pricey for no reason."
  • "The food was poor and way overpriced."
  • "The food was horrible the Angelina salad was so acidic that it was inedible and the fish was greasy."
  • "The food was below par."

Service

Pros:

  • "Was treated like a queen when I arrived."
  • "The service sparkles more than the glassware."
  • "I am overwhelmed by the impeccable service."
  • "The staff at Angelina's really give you that pampered feeling."
  • "The entire staff from Angelina to the waiters are over the top accommodating and friendly."
  • "Service was quick fast and friendly professional and Courteous."
  • "The service was fantastic."

Cons:

  • "We made a 7:15 reservation and sat down at about 7:35 (although there were plenty of open tables when we got there)."
  • "The staff very rude when ask for something they take forever."
  • "The waiter was by far the rudest man I have ever come across in my life."
  • "I had to repeatedly ask for water and for the plates to be removed."
  • "Made reservations for 8pm, seated at 9:15, didn’t eat until 10pm."
  • "The waiter came over and asked how everything was my husbands response was very disappointed. Waiter walked away never came back."
  • "Service was horrible, horrible, horrible. Took over twenty minutes for a 'server' to even come over and ask for our drink order."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "I was impressed by the decor of the outdoor patio. So charming!"
  • "If you’re looking for ambiance, Angelina’s is perfect."
  • "The dining room ambience evokes warmth and the light Italian music makes for a very relaxing atmosphere."
  • "A gorgeous view accompanies and upscale. Very romantic atmosphere."
  • "The ambience is wonderfully bright and airy."
  • "The ambience is so romantic and great for date nights."
  • "The Atmosphere Was wonderful Beautifully decorated."

Cons:

  • "However the atmosphere is ruined by cheap entertainment. Can’t hear yourself speak, can’t hear the waiters over the racket."
  • "The atmosphere and service was TERRIBLE the restaurant was 84 degrees inside, myself and my family were sweating and very uncomfortable."
  • "After a very noisy dinner (quality of food spoiled by ambience)."
  • "It used to be my favorite restaurant but we were very disappointed on father's day dinner. No air-conditioning, very hot and humid and management could not do anything about it."
  • "Everything from the plates, silverware, stem glasses all were dirty."
  • "We were instead seated inside (with no view on the ocean)."
  • "Food didn't taste fresh I couldn't eat it. Shellfish tasted bad, pasta was gummy, balled up and served cold."

Price

Pros:

  • "The food was delicious and well priced."
  • "The price was reasonable and they have my wife a rose as a thank you."
  • "The price was good too!"

Cons:

  • "Then they have the nerve to charge $79 a person plus a 20% tip."
  • "But $500 for 2 people was not worth it."
  • "With the money this restaurant charged for food and drinks, i think they should upgrade their air conditioning."
  • "They are in Hollywood with their prices."
  • "VERY overpriced."
  • "Way way over priced very small portions."
  • "This restaurant is too much expensive."

Event Hosting

Pros:

  • "Had my wedding here 5 years ago, so that in itself should tell you a lot about this restaurant!"
  • "Highly recommended for anyone looking for an unforgettable wedding experience."
  • "The grounds contain Bocce courts (Angelina's hosts a league on Wednesdays), outdoor seating, an outdoor bar and a lavish tent for outdoor affairs."
  • "The event was such a hit with all my guest. The attention to detail, service, food, setup, clean up, made me a guest in my own home."
  • "Choosing Angelina’s Ristorante as our wedding venue was the best decision we made!"
  • "The ambiance was perfect for our special day, and the Bocce tent where we held our event was beautifully decorated, making our wedding day even more magical."
  • "Had daughter and nephew confirmation party Saturday set party up with Christina who excellent at what she does my daughter has allergies so she made sure all was perfect as for food n party and atmosphere everything was perfect great job to owners and staff 5 star from my family no one wanted to leave."

Cons:

  • "They can’t host a good party.in there the owner very nasty to customers she talk to everyone like she owns the world not a stupid restaurant."
  • "Disgraceful and unprofessional for parties!"
  • "Unreliable establishment. Broken agreements."
  • "We did NOT get a courtesy call or a notice that our reservation was changed/canceled."
  • "Not at all helpful or knowledgeable in planning or executing a successful party!"
  • "They were not prepared or set up at 12:00 which was the start time and when guests were arriving at the party."
  • "I would suggest if you make reservations for big events, be ready to have the reservation canceled without notice."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.