Charlie Bird Reviews Summary

Category: Italian restaurant New York

Address: 5 King St, New York, NY 10012, USA

Rating: 4.3
based on 188 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Food was really good."
  • "The food was really great and reminded me of the Mediterranean cuisine a lot."
  • "Incredible food."
  • "The food is really good, cooked to perfection and absolutely tasty."
  • "Food was delicious."
  • "The food was fresh and flavorful."
  • "Food was delicious and well portioned."

Cons:

  • "Very small main entree portions and no sides or salad included."
  • "The portions for some dishes are comically small."
  • "The crab pasta had so much acid you couldn't taste the crab."
  • "Food’s good but a bit hit or miss with the preparation."
  • "The beef carpaccio was a huge disappointment - heavy-honestly slathered in some sort of chilli paste."
  • "The meals were agonizingly disappointing."
  • "Most of the dishes were forgettable and under-seasoned, including the hen of the woods."

Service

Pros:

  • "The amazing, attentive staff."
  • "The service was very good & knowledgeable about the food or wine."
  • "The service was great and we were seated right away."
  • "Hector truly made this one of the top food and restaurant memories in my lifetime."
  • "Excellent service, interesting menu options and worth the walk and find!"
  • "The service was excellent (thank you to the bartender who made those superb whiskey sours), and we are looking forward to returning."
  • "Service was excellent."

Cons:

  • "Despite 45 minutes passing and multiple requests, our drinks never arrived."
  • "The service was also bad. The server was unfriendly and seemed ready to go home."
  • "The waitress never checked on us again after we ordered."
  • "Service took forever."
  • "Service was so terrible. We set for almost 30 minutes and no one came to our table."
  • "The server never came to check on us and every time we wanted something we had to get up and call someone."
  • "Service a little slow and had to wait 10 minutes for our table."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "Come here often. Music adds to the ambiance."
  • "An enjoyable night (was in a private dining room, but the main restaurant was equally relaxed and enjoyable)."
  • "The atmosphere was really fun and the service was incredible."
  • "The atmosphere is classy, trendy, but most of all fun - great rap/hip hop tunes over fine wine and Italian."
  • "The atmosphere and decor of the place is perfect."
  • "We were delighted with service and atmosphere in this cozy but sunny restaurant."
  • "Atmosphere was beautiful."

Cons:

  • "It's very cold in their outdoor space and regardless of how good the food was, we couldn't wait to leave."
  • "The blasting music is unbearable though, and also it is quite a horrible choice to accompany meals - full bast rap."
  • "Overall the space is cramped and the music very loud which makes conversation challenging."
  • "The music gave me a headache."
  • "Space was really, really tight. You are basically on top of one another."
  • "Inside was too loud, a cacophony."
  • "Only complaint was it was VERY loud and made conversation difficult."

Value

Pros:

  • "The wine, a rose we normally wouldn't try but did due to the weather and the waitress suggestion, was fantastic."
  • "Wonderful oysters and pasta dishes. The pasta is a great al dente and the oysters are really fresh."
  • "Prices were good."
  • "I found the prices very reasonable too."
  • "Prices are def on the expensive side but worth it."
  • "Charlie Bird is damn well worth every penny."
  • "The wine list is phenomenal and well constructed."

Cons:

  • "Sadly it’s just not worth it."
  • "Overall, huge waste of money."
  • "Wine was fine but for $25 I expected a REAL pour."
  • "The mains were so small but on the high end of the price spectrum."
  • "Also, they offer $4 oysters. What a joke!"
  • "It’s completely overpriced for mediocre bottles of wine."
  • "The pricing for the portions was laughable. The chocolate dessert was the size of a quarter."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.