The Attic Reviews Summary

Category: Oyster bar restaurant New York

Address: 136-93 37th Ave, Queens, NY 11354, USA

Phone: +19293290005

Rating: 4.7
based on 113 reviews.

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "When we went through the door the atmosphere seemed pretty cool and they seated us pretty fast."
  • "The atmosphere is so amazing."
  • "The atmosphere was amazing and has its own unique style, good music playlist."
  • "This place is really an experience from the moment you walk in and leave your host would make you feel cozy!"
  • "Hard to describe this place. The spot is gorgeous and the staff well dressed, but there's no stiffness or lack of warmth at all."
  • "The decor is beautiful and vintage. Pretty cozy nook for dates and vibes."
  • "Such an eclectic and cool atmosphere with decor inspired by various cultures and eras."

Cons:

  • "Didn't eat here just went in to see if we can catch a few drinks but I was only able to get one. The place was reserved and extremely small inside I felt very claustrophobic in there."
  • "It was weird the serving staff was counting tips from a table that was about to leave like right in front of them."
  • "The place is small. I wasn't kidding when I said intimate. Bring people you don't mind being in close proximity to."
  • "Unfortunately, the biggest let down was how unclean and dusty this place was."
  • "Went and sat at the bar. Felt like we weren’t wanted."
  • "I then left, and refuse to return. This community in flushing made African Americans super uncomfortable."
  • "Two large roaches approached our table, one went on my friends neck and the other went to my other friend's shoe."

Service

Pros:

  • "Eric was one of the first bartenders I've met and gave me the best service a customer could ask for."
  • "Service was awesome too! Our waitress was so fun and bubbly!"
  • "We sat at the bar, where there was attentive, friendly service."
  • "You can tell how a place is by the staff. They are comfortable working and they don't hesitate to make your drink, bring your food, get an extra fork etc."
  • "Service is impeccable and food is excellent."
  • "The service being attentive and friendly."
  • "The staff and bartender were wonderful."

Cons:

  • "One didn’t even say anything when putting down the plates, just dropped them on the table suddenly."
  • "Had to pour our own wine bottle. It wasn't busy on a Wednesday so not an excuse."
  • "Service was really bad and very slow and the place wasn't even packed."
  • "Service was not the best, maybe not waitress night and she was by herself. But cut and dry."
  • "The waitress was very curt and rushed us through out the entire meal."
  • "The only thing was that when it was hh, it took a long time to get drinks."
  • "The bartenders vibe and energy towards us was very dry and made us feel very uncomfortable."

Food & Drinks

Pros:

  • "THE BEST LOBSTER ROLL IN TOWN!"
  • "The clams stole all my attention πŸ₯° The hamburger it was delicious."
  • "The seafood was fresh and the truffle Parm fries were nice and crispy!"
  • "The drinks they have on the menu are so delicious and pretty."
  • "The $1.50 happy hour oysters were such a steal and the lychee cocktail was delicious."
  • "The oysters here are very good quality and consist of Kumamoto and Copps Island."
  • "BOMBEST oysters here. Their happy hour with oysters and drinks are absolutely great."

Cons:

  • "Food wasn't bad, but I wouldn't call it amazing."
  • "Don’t expect good quality about the Oysters from the happy hours."
  • "The food options are limited and also pricey."
  • "For $35 for that, I would have expected more and better."
  • "The drinks are too light, no alcohol at all."
  • "The lobster roll was sad. Not much flavor, no butter and minimal lobster."
  • "Then I order the short rib” God help me this tasted like old beef."

Value

Pros:

  • "One of my favorite bars this year."
  • "The hh prices were very reasonable."
  • "Prices are reasonable and I can't wait to return another night!!"
  • "Definitely higher end cocktails. Especially needed in this area."
  • "This is my go-to spot in Queens for amazing cocktails, swanky decor, and overall amazing energy."
  • "Best speakeasy cocktail bar in Queens, NYC!"
  • "The best cocktails in Flushing!"

Cons:

  • "Imagine making a reservation two weeks in advance, only to be told the day before that there is a $65 per person minimum that must be met for parties greater than 6 people."
  • "The wine had a markup of 200% for a 2020. πŸ‘Ž"
  • "Drinks are a little pricey but I would recommend getting the Cha Cha Cha drink."
  • "Drinks are 16$ and up. Food is expensive too not a big menu not many vegetarian options."
  • "That said $17 a pop for flushing is definitely on the higher end."
  • "For $35 dollars, the lobster roll came in a small hamburger bun and I felt it was a waste of money."
  • "In conclusion, seems like it could be a nice place to grab a drink but it'll definitely put a dent in your wallet."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.